The Scary of Sixty-First

Play trailer

1:34

The Scary of Sixty-First

Released Dec 2, 2021

1h 21m

Horror

Mystery & Thriller

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

54%

Tomatometer

41 Reviews

46%

Popcornmeter

Fewer than 50 Ratings

While out apartment hunting, college pals Noelle and Addie stumble upon the deal of a lifetime: a posh duplex on Manhattan's Upper East Side. But soon after moving in, a more sinister picture of the apartment emerges when a mysterious woman arrives and claims the property used to belong to the infamous and recently-deceased Jeffrey Epstein. With this news, Noelle becomes obsessed with the visitor--to the point of infatuation. As the pair plunge deeper into the conspiracies of the Epstein case, Addie falls into her own bizarre state: a pseudo-possession complete with inexplicable fits of age-regressed sexual mania. As they peel back on these strange occurrences, the truth reveals itself to be more twisted than they could have ever imagined.

Critics Consensus

It's hard not to admire its often ungainly attempts to achieve its ambitions, but The Scary of Sixty-First is a horror provocation that disappoints as often as it thrills.

Read Critics Reviews

Cath Clarke

Guardian

To me this feels like a silly smirking film with zero insights into abuse or conspiracy theories.

Rated: 2/5

Mar 1, 2022

Full Review

Becca James

Chicago Reader

All of this takes place in what Nekrasova has likened to Eyes Wide Shut New York, and it is, in fact, as alluring as its influences, pulling viewers into a film that teeters between absurdly funny and absurdly frightening.

Jan 22, 2022

Full Review

Stephen Romei

The Australian

As important as that subject is, this film doesn't work for me. I think it's contrived and pointless. It tells us nothing new.

Rated: 2/5

Jan 8, 2022

Full Review

Ygraine Hackett-Cantabrana

The Geek Show (UK)

Do we really need a film where the despicable actions of sexual abusers are brushed off as the fault of Satan and his followers, or should this have been a film that held Epstein and others like him accountable?

Jul 9, 2024

Full Review

Sarah Ward

Concrete Playground

The Scary of Sixty-First doesn't always completely come together, but Nekrasova has crafted an uncompromising and compelling movie that plays like a slap in the face and isn't easily forgotten.

Jul 8, 2022

Full Review

Eve Tushnet

Patheos

This is a movie where when you hear what it is, your first reaction is gonna be, “That should not have been made,” and while I often defend that kind of movie… this movie should not have been made.

Mar 21, 2022

Full Review

Read all reviews

Francisco P

Absolutely engaging and an interesting take on such new and horrid subject matter. The movie has such great static shots that go further and Dasha Nekrasova made a fine debut effort, I expect to see more from her soon.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

03/04/25

Full Review

Jessica M

I want my 3.99 back. The trailer and premise got my attention. This was horrible though.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

10/13/24

Full Review

Harris T

I can't believe after all my years of watching movies I made the rookie mistake of trusting the trailer. Shame on me.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

09/20/24

Full Review

Jeffrey P

Epstein conspiracy theory horror film that you've all been waiting for. The style and sound are decent, the retro vibe is enough to carry it when nothing else does... and then it ends.

Rated 3 out of 5 stars

11/12/23

Full Review

Tom D

Just don't. But if you must, wait until you can watch it for free. You'll regret that $3.99 you spent to rent it. I can't think of any movie EVER that was as bad as this.

Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars

10/30/23

Full Review

Chelsea L

The Jeffrey Epstein thing was a little gross - like too soon and not funny- but it was mostly the bag wigs that did it for me. This was awful.

Rated 1.5 out of 5 stars

06/10/23

Full Review

Read all reviews

Read More

Read Less

POST RATING

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

Dasha Nekrasova

Director

Betsey Brown

Addie

Madeline Quinn

Noelle

Stephen Gurewitz

The Realtor

Dasha Nekrasova

The Girl

Aaron Dalla Villa

Crystal Shop Customer

Held

39%

62%

Held

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Held

Hall

78%

7%

Hall

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Hall

Gateway

89%

96%

Gateway

Watchlist

W Lesie Dzis nie Zasnie Nikt

67%

28%

W Lesie Dzis nie Zasnie Nikt

Watchlist

Woe

83%

0%

Woe

Watchlist

Discover more movies and TV shows.

View More

The Scary of Sixty-First: Trailer 1

1:34

View more videos

View more photos

Synopsis

While out apartment hunting, college pals Noelle and Addie stumble upon the deal of a lifetime: a posh duplex on Manhattan's Upper East Side. But soon after moving in, a more sinister picture of the apartment emerges when a mysterious woman arrives and claims the property used to belong to the infamous and recently-deceased Jeffrey Epstein. With this news, Noelle becomes obsessed with the visitor--to the point of infatuation. As the pair plunge deeper into the conspiracies of the Epstein case, Addie falls into her own bizarre state: a pseudo-possession complete with inexplicable fits of age-regressed sexual mania. As they peel back on these strange occurrences, the truth reveals itself to be more twisted than they could have ever imagined.

Director: Dasha Nekrasova
Producer: Adam Mitchell, Mark H. Rapaport, Adam Mitchell, Mark H. Rapaport
Screenwriter: Dasha Nekrasova, Madeline Quinn
Distributor: Utopia
Production Co: Carnegie Hill Entertainment, Spacemaker Productions, Kinematics
Genre: Horror, Mystery & Thriller
Original Language: English
Release Date (Theaters): Dec 2, 2021, Limited
Release Date (Streaming): Dec 24, 2021
Runtime: 1h 21m

Most Popular at Home Now