Rotten Tomatoes
Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Enigma

Play trailer 1:56 Poster for Enigma 2025 1h 34m Documentary LGBTQ+ Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
Tomatometer 7 Reviews Popcornmeter Fewer than 50 Ratings
Exploring transgender identity and legacy and chronicling the divergent paths of iconic pioneers April Ashley, Amanda Lear, and others, acclaimed filmmaker Zackary Drucker explores questions of identity and survival, revealing the disparate but intertwined stories of women whose lives helped shape trans culture and history. Their experiences, varied and complex, highlight the costs associated with living their truths and explore what is gained and lost by defining their identities.
Watch on HBO Max Stream Now

Where to Watch

Enigma

Critics Reviews

View More
Glenn Dunks reDocumented Mar 8, 2026
When all is said and done, Enigma does come across as a bit of muckraking. Which is (maybe) actually fine with me, but it is questionable in how it goes about it. Go to Full Review
Stephen A. Russell Orion's Shoulder (Substack) Dec 31, 2025
Drucker’s interested in the truth, but never disrespectful, in a rollicking doco that’s packed with jaw-dropping moments. Go to Full Review
John Paul King Washington Blade Jul 7, 2025
The contrast between the life each of these women chose to live speaks volumes, and makes “Enigma” into one of the most interesting — and truthful — trans documentaries to emerge thus far. Go to Full Review
John Serba Decider Jun 29, 2025
In an age of celeb-puff-piece documentaries, it’s rare to see such tension between interviewer and subject. Go to Full Review
Pat Mullen POV Magazine Jun 26, 2025
The non-answers in Enigma prove as satisfying as the answers do. If not more so. Go to Full Review
Christopher Campbell Nonfics (Substack) Jun 20, 2025
The film veers toward disrespect in its hounding of [Amanda Lear], not to mention its inclusion of her so prominently in such a documentary. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Dan C @cinemacriterion Jul 3, 2025 Fascinating story! Zackary Drucker proving to be a documentarian to watch. See more Judy B @RT92101771 Jun 30, 2025 Really fascinating. I was a teenager in the seventies and immediately recognized "Amanda Lear" as a top fashion model. I had seen her picture in "Vogue" and other similar publications. Never in a million years would I have thought she was a man. And, indeed, throughout the film she was maddeningly coy about her true gender identity. She claimed to have learned that it was beneficial to never actually tell the truth from her friend and mentor Salavador Dali. But the story unfolded in such a way that I believed by the end that she had been born male, and obtained gender reassignment surgery at a time when that was very expensive and rare. She worked, before her modeling break, at Le Carrousel, in the red light district in Paris. There she had a different name, Peki (forget the last name). She met and was best friends with the other transwoman profiled in "Enigma", April Ashley, a British woman whose story was far more emotionally affecting and who was much more open than "Amanda". Her vulnerability made her seem much more human and able to help other transfolks making that difficult transition. This film probably has a very limited audience, which is a shame, because it really reveals a side of life that many people can't even imagine. April Ashley attempted suicide twice as a young person, she was outed in the middle of her modeling career and so that opportunity collapsed, then she became a very successful restauranteur. She was very beautiful also. One could not help but feel that if only the world would be more accepting of people's differences, much tragedy could be avoided. See more Michelle H. @shelby060863 Jun 28, 2025 I loved hearing April’s story. Amanda couldn’t tell the truth if her life depended on it. I am so disappointed. See more Stephen C @bob25009 Jun 28, 2025 Success in 1 hour and 34 minutes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! See more Read all reviews
Enigma

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

Movie Info

Synopsis Exploring transgender identity and legacy and chronicling the divergent paths of iconic pioneers April Ashley, Amanda Lear, and others, acclaimed filmmaker Zackary Drucker explores questions of identity and survival, revealing the disparate but intertwined stories of women whose lives helped shape trans culture and history. Their experiences, varied and complex, highlight the costs associated with living their truths and explore what is gained and lost by defining their identities.
Director
Zackary Drucker
Producer
Madison Passarelli, Douglas Banker, Alex Garinger, Noah Levy, Donovan Lovell, Stephen Strout
Distributor
Max
Production Co
Five All in the Fifth, HBO Documentary Films
Genre
Documentary, LGBTQ+
Original Language
English
Release Date (Streaming)
Jun 24, 2025
Runtime
1h 34m
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings