U-Carmen Ekhayelitsha

Audience Reviews

View More

01/17/2012 This seems like the kind of thing I would be all over: a click language translation of an opera. But something about it just doesn't work for me. I suspect it may be Carmen itself, and not the reinvention. See more 07/21/2010 Should have done it as a contemporary African hip hop opera. Probably more peeps would appreciated it more. To me, it's still a very splendid production for what it was. See more 04/16/2010 I enjoyed this movie despite not liking the opera carmen. See more 04/13/2010 The only reason melodrama of this sort works at the opera is because its the freakin' opera. EVERYTHING is larger than life and ridiculous. This film's fatal error is depicting the melodrama in an extremely realist style, complete with hand-held cameras. The result is that I feel I'm watching neither a spectacle nor a depiction of real life. See more 10/24/2009 One of the most brilliant and fresh versions of Bizet's opera "Carmen" I have ever seen! If you just keep in mind that the action occurs in the late 20th century South Africa and Carmen is a passionate woman living in a Cape Town slum district called Khayelitsha, the remaining elements of the plot are not very distant to the original text. Surprisingly, the result is an exotic and colorful show, enhanced with superb and powerful black voices. A great discovery! See more 06/03/2008 I love opera and I love when opera's timeless stories are well-translated into novel settings (my favourites are Peter Sellars' Mozart series)-- this brilliantly sung Carmen, in the Xhosa language, and weaving spoken dialogue into Bizet's music, set in a South African township, is utterly compelling and gripping-- beautifully acted, full of strong and mesmerizing faces, it celebrates the strength, turbulence and sensuality of modern African communal life. See more Read all reviews

U-Carmen Ekhayelitsha

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW