We Could Still Be Pen Pals

Audience Reviews

View More (4)

Michael L Great movie about the live of kids seeking advice and comfort. Covers a touching story about how one tries to help continue this momentum while having a twisted dark side. Comedic, funny, slightly twisted Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 08/23/25 Full Review Marcie D. Such a great independent film with an original plot! Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 07/18/25 Full Review athena d I have started watching more independent films lately. I loved this one. Its heartfelt and shows growth. I'm so tired of big Hollywood making movies without a soul. You can watch this with your children around and not be worried about what they might see. Its definitely worth the watch. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 07/14/25 Full Review TheMovieSearch R This indie film is a quiet, heartfelt exploration of grief, growth, and human connection, and it succeeds most when it focuses on its emotional core. Director did a fantastic job assembling the film and guiding the story’s tender moments. The writing is layered, heartfelt, and clearly crafted with care, offering moments that feel both authentic and moving. The standout performance comes from Alec Dean Boeschen as Damian. He delivers a raw, emotional, and incredibly balanced performance, moving seamlessly between joy and heartbreak. His character’s arc is the glue that holds the film together, and his talent shines in every scene. Christine Celozzi, portraying Lindsay, complements him beautifully, bringing depth to her scenes and creating a chemistry that carries much of the story’s emotional weight. River Downing, who plays young Damian, is quietly moving as well, capturing the innocence and anxiety of a child navigating growing up, school, and creative expression. Unfortunately, the casting falters in some key moments. Donnakelli Barnett as Miss Lewis is meant to be the heart of the story, a character whose presence should linger even after death, but her performance never quite connects. Instead of feeling authentic, her portrayal comes across as forced, leaving viewers emotionally detached. Certain scenes also feel oddly muted. A college party, for example, is subdued to the point of distraction—the extras appear lifeless, and the camera draws attention to unintended details, like a man at a window whose appearance pulls focus from the story. These moments break immersion and prevent the film from fully engaging the audience. That said, when the film centers on Damian and his relationship with the teacher’s granddaughter, it truly shines. These interactions are tender, believable, and moving, offering the kind of quiet emotional payoff that makes indie films like this memorable. Overall, this is a sweet, heartfelt film with genuine emotional power. While there are notable flaws in casting and some scene execution, the core story of connection and growth is compelling. For $1.99 on Amazon Prime, it’s absolutely worth a watch for anyone looking for a quiet, thoughtful story about love, loss, and personal discovery. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 11/20/25 Full Review Read all reviews

We Could Still Be Pen Pals

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now