Episode 1
Aired Aug 23, 2020
I Killed Dirty John
Terra Newell her mother, Debra, discover evil tendencies in Debra's new man, John Meehan, but Terra never imagined she would ultimately be forced to kill him.
Details
Episode 2
Aired Aug 30, 2020
I Didn't Know It Was Blood
Christina Hildreth unwittingly helped Shawn Grate clean up his first crime scene, she didn't realize what she was doing.
Details
Episode 3
Aired Sep 6, 2020
I Don't Believe in Forgiveness
Teri Knight spent weeks driving cross-country, desperately searching for the secret her ex-husband, Manuel Gehring, took to his grave; it took years before a stranger finally solved the mystery.
Details
Episode 4
Aired Sep 13, 2020
Momma Made Me Help
Shirley Furgala helps her mother, Betty Lou Beets, drag a dead body into the yard and bury it, but Shirley doesn't know that this won't be the last time her mother will ask for help.
Details
Episode 5
Aired Oct 4, 2020
The Prom Night Killer
In 1989, Jessi Toronjo goes to a sleepover thinking her stepbrother, Jeffrey Pelley, is at his senior prom; she spends the next 13 years believing someone else killed her family members, only to discover she knew the killer all along.
Details
Episode 5
Aired Sep 20, 2020
My Love for My Boy Is Unchanged
A more intimate interview with the Keller family surfaces new information; they never suspected the man terrorizing their city could be one of their own.
Details
Episode 6
Aired Oct 18, 2020
My Son Broke My Heart
Vickie Webb's son is accused of absolute evil, and she isn't surprised.
Details
Episode 7
Aired Oct 11, 2020
My Mother's Lies
As a teen, Cindy Taylor's world is shattered by the sudden death of her father; years later, Cindy learns that her own mother is involved in the death.
Details
Episode 7
Aired Oct 25, 2020
They Found Them in Storage
Wilda Gadd dismissed rumors she heard about Howard Willis when she married him, but it wasn't until she found herself wearing a wire and risking her life that she finally realized the truth.
Details
Episode 10
Aired Feb 21, 2021
He Still Haunts Me
An extended interview with Gwen Bailey, who married Norman Starnes; she discovered she never really knew him at all; she was his unwilling accomplice.
Details
Episode 11
Aired Feb 28, 2021
Was It Worth Killing For?
When Eric Witte was a boy, his father taught him to protect his family; as Eric's father grew increasingly violent, Eric realized he needed to protect his family from his father.
Details
Episode 12
Aired Mar 7, 2021
Judith Made Me Do It
When Corey Breininger was a child, his stepmother, Judith Hawkey, coerced him into doing something horrible.
Details
>
