Brigadoon

Audience Reviews

View More

William R @RT95177156 Aug 23 Shot in Cinemascope a turgidly directed by Vincente Minelli this really is a travesty both of 17th century Scotland and the original Broadway musical. Part of the problem is some of the original plot has been deleted but also nobody can handle the camera - no closeups just static shots of lots of fake Scottish dancing - sometimes quite spectacular but all to often shot at night so distinctly hard to see what is going on. Van Johnson is wasted as the wise cracking New Yorker on a hunting trip with chum Gene Kelly when, for no good reason, they get lost in the mist and discover Brigadoon which only comes to life once every 100 years because the local minister wanted to protect his flock from witches. The villagers appear to wake up and not to question anything not even the strangers and naturally Kelly fall for Cyd Charisse - they dance quite frequently - but goes home only to find he cannot do without her and cannot stand his New York fiance so he goes back and for some reason Brigadoon wakes up and lets him in. It closes as the two meet but not actually in a clinch. It really is how not to take a tricky show - the original can work and I have seen a production in London, although not the 2025 one - and transfer it to the screen. Minelli was definitely having an off day and the evidence is there on screen. The songs are lovely, the out takes interesting and the trailer lies like mad See more D S @RT71052616 Jul 15 Wonderfully done musical. See more S S @RT68182152 Jul 15 Underrated gem. I remember watching this movie with my family when I was a kid on PBS. The musical numbers are lovely and showcase Gene Kelly and Cyd Charisse’s dancing skills and his lovely voice. The movie is missing some wonderful musical numbers, but they are included on some versions of the DVD. See more Steve D @RT35616104 01/23/2024 Some good actors but unconvincing. See more Phil S @RT31403343 12/05/2023 So madly in love with Cyd which frightened the neighborhood until they realized I meant Charrise, not Caesar! See more Josh G @RT66757610 04/12/2023 A dull and drawn out color festival on a studio back lot. It has all the charm of Gene Kelly trying to make this work but the script, music and director giving up and making it long and dull. Meh........ See more Read all reviews

Brigadoon

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now