Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Maddie's Secret

Play trailer Maddie's Secret 2025 1h 38m Comedy Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
88% Tomatometer 17 Reviews Popcornmeter 0 Ratings

Critics Reviews

View More
Adam Nayman The Ringer Sep 16
If that sounds like a recipe for disaster, Early aces his own high-degree-of-difficulty assignment by leveraging his alt-comic instincts against a reverent (and revelatory) cinephilia. Go to Full Review Kristy Puchko Mashable Sep 16
John Early is a better ingénue than Sydney Sweeney. Go to Full Review Zachary Lee RogerEbert.com Sep 11
'Maddie’s Secret’ challenges us that we don’t have to follow the world’s recipe for success; we’re capable and beloved well enough that we can freestyle on our own and still be whole. Go to Full Review Joe Lipsett The Queer Gaze (Podcast) Oct 21
1/5
Even when you understand the genesis of Early's project, it doesn't make the film more fun or tolerable. Despite the solid cast, the comedy feels insufferable and the storytelling and messaging are wildly inconsistent Go to Full Review Elissa Suh Moviepudding (Substack) Sep 15
The culmination of Early’s usual wit and what appears to be an impressive cinematic sensibility. Go to Full Review Jake Kring-Schreifels The Film Stage Sep 14
Early has a natural way with the camera, leaning on close-ups to capture micro expressions and further sud up all the soapiness. In both words and images, Maddie’s Secret is ripped straight from the afterschool-special playbook. Go to Full Review Read all reviews

Cast & Crew

View All

John Early

Director

John Early

Actor

Kate Berlant

Actor

Eric Rahill

Actor

Kristen Johnston

Actor

Claudia O'Doherty

Actor
View All

Maddie's Secret

View more photos

Movie Info

Director
John Early
Producer
Harris Mayersohn, Luca Intili, John Early
Screenwriter
John Early
Production Co
Dogma 3000, Unapologetic Projects, Dweck Productions, Whetstone Pictures, Radish Films
Genre
Comedy
Original Language
English
Runtime
1h 38m