Mystery Island: Winner Takes All

Name: Mystery Island: Winner Takes All
Genre: Mystery & Thriller
Released: 2025-03-13
Cast: Elizabeth Henstridge, Charlie Weber, Kristin Booth

Play trailer

2025

1h 24m

Mystery & Thriller

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

Tomatometer

1 Reviews

Popcornmeter

Fewer than 50 Ratings

Contest winners try to solve a fake murder for a grand prize, but the event goes awry when a real murder occurs and secrets are uncovered.

Liz Kocan

Decider

I’ve long felt that the movies on Hallmark Mystery are among some of the best Hallmark has to offer, they often have great casts and clever plots that sprinkle in a lot of silly fun. Mystery Island: Winner Takes All is a great example of that.

Mar 17, 2025

Full Review

Read all reviews

Marisa R

Worse than the first one.The two main actors are do not create characters that are engaging whatsoever. They don’t have the charm or characters that you care about like Aurora, Teagarden, or garage sale mysteries

Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars

03/21/25

Full Review

Tiffany G

Review: https://wp.me/p65txm-h5I/#MysteryIsland

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

03/16/25

Full Review

Jim A

I hadn’t seen the first one, and after watching this one, I’m quite certain I won’t. The acting throughout is wooden, and surprisingly that is true for the leads as well. It comes off like a community theater production of Clue.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

03/15/25

Full Review

Read all reviews

Read Less

POST RATING

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

Elizabeth Henstridge

Dr. Emilia Priestly

Charlie Weber

Jason Trent

Kristin Booth

Cassandra

John Christian Plummer

Writer

Trevor Aikman

Film Editing

View more photos

Synopsis

Contest winners try to solve a fake murder for a grand prize, but the event goes awry when a real murder occurs and secrets are uncovered.

Screenwriter: John Christian Plummer
Genre: Mystery & Thriller
Original Language: English
Release Date (TV): Mar 13, 2025
Runtime: 1h 24m

Email not verified

Let's keep in touch!

Sign up for the Rotten Tomatoes newsletter to get weekly updates on:

Let's keep in touch!

Sign up for the Rotten Tomatoes newsletter to get weekly updates on:

Mystery Island: Winner Takes All

Critics Reviews

Audience Reviews

My Rating

Cast & Crew

Photos