P.S. I Love You

Audience Reviews

View More (1000+)

Pia P A fantastic film! I've probably watched this a hundred times by now and it never disappoints. The plot, storyline is realistic. What most people don't realise is Swank is playing a 30 year old who doesn't know what she wants out of life whilst her husband, Gerry is alive. Hence the constant anger, frustration and arguments. The love existed which she took for granted until her cards were dealt and life happened. Death is a part of life and Holly (Swanks character) still had some growing up to do so the shock of it all led her to spiral. Swank caught the essense very well. As a woman, I can understand the reactions and mood swings she experienced. Not an easy role for anyone,especially since she is the main character. She did brilliantly! A realist would make a great critic for this film. Gerard Butler, though had snippets in the film came across amazing as an Irish (actually Scottish in real life), comical bright light of a man. Very vast as an actor since he's done more action roles, but clearly has the ability to hold down Rom-Com movies. Swank has also said Gerard is husband material during an interview. I can see that. Would love to see him in another. A film to help any age to get through every level of grief. Well worth a watch! Will always be a favourite! Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 10/01/25 Full Review Robson C Após a morte do seu marido, Holly começa a receber cartas escritas por ele que vão lhe ajudando a sair do luto. Assistindo a este filme, entendi o porquê dele ter se tornado uma espécie de clássico das comédias românticas. E isso se de principalmente pelo talento e a química do casal principal: Gerard Butler e Hillary Swank. Não há como não se convencer que Gerry não é apaixonado por Holly. Basta olhar para os olhos de Butler, que chegam a brilhar. Além disso, temos um elenco de grande talento reunido: Kathy Bates, Lisa Kudrow, Gina Gershon, Jeffrey Dean Morgan. Além da surpresa de ver Harry Connick Jr no papel mais desconcertante do filme: um homem que quando abre a boca, sai as coisas mais inesperadas e sinceras possíveis. Completando isso, temos um roteiro bem redondo e esperto, com boas sacadas, que constrói bons personagens, além de fazer o público chorar nos momentos certos. E uma direção que sabe que o que tem, não precisa reinventar nada, apenas conduzir a todos ao final. O filme não promete finais felizes, mas possibilidades que só dependem de Holly. A cena do velório no bar ao som de Fairytale of New York, com os Pogues e Kisty MacColl é, ao mesmo tempo, hilária e emocionante. Um sentimento bittersweet que envolve o filme inteiro. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 06/14/25 Full Review Deborah C I was disappointed for any bad reviews! I loved the story, acting of all rolls. At first I wasn't sure about H. Swank but as the story goes on she was perfect for the role and superb acting. Love G.Butler as well. H. Connick Jr love him he is under rated always! Remember hewas a singer first, then went to acting. He can do anything and a good Christian man! At first I was disappointed Harry wasn't the lead role but then fell in love with G.B. THIS movie was about several things and I felt every stage of grief that she felt! Also I want to go to Ireland now but am amputee in wheelchair so not sure how much accessibility! My son has Asburger Syndrome so Harry did an excellent portrayal! Go Harry Connick Jr,your#1 fan! Rated 4.5/5 Stars •  Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars 03/15/25 Full Review Noel R Thank god RT has elevated the audience scores, this is one of MANY examples where critics do not know what the hell a movie is aiming for. Nobody in this movie was trying to win an award, they acted their parts just fine. I think these reviews are the basis for the episode of the office where they debate Hillary Swank. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 02/12/25 Full Review L M Always coming back to see this movie mainly because of the story. I rarely cry, but when I need to cry because of being sad, or randomly I want to cry not because of being sad, this is the movie. start to end just crying like hell yeah this feels right. I don’t care about the casting, everything is beautifully made. mostly because the story is good and touching. Love it! Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 07/28/24 Full Review Patricia L This film is so underrated. It is a love story. Maybe it is because it talks of the reality of death and how to cope. I saw this film not long after my husband had passed after his cancer battle so I could relate. This film helped me with my grieving process. I bought my own DVD copy and I must have played it many times. I thought the cast was excellent. I also loved the music. The story is sad, funny, and hopeful. The critics were far too harsh on this film; I do not understand why. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 03/12/24 Full Review Read all reviews

P.S. I Love You

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now