The Smurfs: The Legend of Smurfy Hollow

Audience Reviews

View More

TheMovieSearch R @TheMovieSearch 08/11/2024 Smurfs: The Legend of Smurfy Hollow is a short, playful animated entry in the Smurfs universe—one that manages to bring viewers back into the familiar blue world without fully restoring the momentum the franchise once had. It’s charming in its own modest way, but it also reminds you how fragmented the Smurfs brand has become over the years. While the animation is cute and accessible for young children, the film struggles to rise above its reputation as another small piece of a larger, inconsistent IP. The short leans heavily on the classic characters—primarily Smurfette and Papa Smurf—which has become a pattern in recent adaptations. The Smurfs have a rich roster of personalities, yet modern interpretations rarely explore beyond the same familiar faces. This limits the storytelling potential and gives the impression that the franchise is afraid to expand, resulting in predictable, repetitive narratives. Despite the colorful aesthetic, the story feels like a retread rather than a fresh adventure. Part of the disconnect comes from modernizing a property that was originally created for a very different era. The Smurfs as a concept still hold nostalgic charm, but translating that into contemporary storytelling has never fully clicked. The writing often feels rushed or shallow, offering just enough plot to engage very young viewers without giving older fans anything substantial to latch onto. As a result, the film feels safe, pleasant, and ultimately forgettable. Voice casting has also become an ongoing issue for the franchise, especially with the constant recasting of Smurfette. Audiences went from Katy Perry to Demi Lovato and then to Rihanna in different projects, which makes it increasingly difficult to take the character seriously or establish any sense of vocal identity. Continuity matters—even in animated family films—and the inconsistency contributes to the sense that the Smurfs brand doesn’t quite know what it wants to be. Even within its short runtime, Smurfs: The Legend of Smurfy Hollow sometimes feels like it’s trying too hard to recapture a magic that has slowly slipped away. It’s cute and harmless for children under six—bright colors, simple jokes, a gentle spooky theme—but it doesn’t offer much staying power. Older kids and teens will find very little to keep their interest, and adults will likely just be waiting for the credits. In the end, this entry is far from terrible—it’s sweet, visually fun, and perfectly suitable for its intended audience. But it also reinforces the larger problem: the Smurfs need a genuine creative overhaul if they ever hope to appeal beyond the smallest of viewers. A new Smurfs movie could work someday, but it will require stronger storytelling, stable casting, and the courage to explore characters beyond the same two blue faces we’ve seen for decades. See more Leticia q 08/26/2023 Uhhhhhhhh…. This sucks See more 11/18/2022 Better than the live action movies. See more 05/14/2021 I love this one! Gutsy Smurf is the best! See more 08/15/2019 I'll just cut the crap and get straight to the point here: Unremarkable but doesn't mean it's not better than the movies. Maybe it's because the Smurfs lend themselves better to animation than they do to live-action, especially 2D animation. See more 07/01/2018 Why keep making the movies I’m not a fan. At least kids may enjoy it See more Read all reviews

The Smurfs: The Legend of Smurfy Hollow

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now