Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Limited Series – Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy

Play trailer 1:18 Poster for Limited Series – Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy Oct 2025 Crime Drama Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
95% Tomatometer 22 Reviews 86% Popcornmeter 100+ Ratings
When teenager Rob Piest goes missing in the Chicago area, the prime suspect is revealed to be an affable and well-liked local businessman named John Wayne Gacy. As officers tail, interrogate and eventually arrest Gacy, it becomes clear to the Des Plaines Police Department that the young man is just one of many who have disappeared at his hands. Lieutenant Joe Kozenczak and Detective Rafael Tovar lead the investigation that uncovers the remains of 32 young men and boys Gacy murdered, as well as the holes in the system that allowed Gacy to evade detection and capture for more than seven years. Meanwhile, a rivalry ensues between Gacy's lead defense lawyer, Sam Amirante, and the local prosecutor, William Kunkle, as the former tries to prevent Gacy's execution while the families attempt to understand how and why their sons were taken from them.
Watch on Fandango at Home Stream Now

Where to Watch

Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy — Limited Series

Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy — Limited Series

What to Know

Critics Consensus

Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy offers a compassionate, morally clear reexamination of the infamous killer's crimes that honors victims and finds fresh purpose in retelling their stories.

Read Critics Reviews

Critics Reviews

View More
Melanie McFarland Salon.com Oct 31
Such a measured approach enables the real people still connected to the story to retain their humanity and dignity. Go to Full Review
Craig Mathieson The Age (Australia) Oct 23
3/5
You don’t witness the many murders of Gacy (Michael Chernus), but you get a sense of his victims and the immense pain left in Gacy’s wake. I appreciated the care and professionalism. Go to Full Review
Roxana Hadadi New York Magazine/Vulture Oct 20
Devil in Disguise doesn’t try to implicate its audience in the sport of watching true crime. Instead, it asks us to care about actual victims rather than abstract arguments of creative license, and it doesn’t disguise that compassion. Go to Full Review
Melissa Camacho Common Sense Media Oct 28
3/5
Designed to remind us that every person's life has value and worth protecting, and of what can happen when we don't. Go to Full Review
Kate Sánchez But Why Tho? A Geek Community Oct 27
8.5/10
Wonderfully acted and grounded in every way that it can be, Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy sets a new standard for true crime series. Go to Full Review
Alan French Sunshine State Cineplex Oct 24
8/10
With a very good, non-showy performance at the center, Devil in Disguise is far less scandalous than its Netflix counterparts. The willingness to engage with the harm done to the victims families also speaks to a frustrating part of the true crime genre. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Lala R Nov 24 Absolutely loved it. Tough real-life story but the directors and writers did an excellent job telling the stories from the point of view of the families, law enforcement and victims. I’m so glad it wasn’t full of gore and clowns! And it didn’t sensationalize John Wayne. The actors were all absolutely amazing portraying their role. Thank you to the writers and directors for providing a riveting series.Bravo!! See more Lioz E Nov 15 It seems like we’re getting back to the days when, in the name of morality, the actual story is censored. Although Monster (the Netflix anthology) and Devil sound similar, the latter prefers not to let you see the monster. Part of these kinds of stories is the complexity of the characters and the fascinating pathologies they have. It seems like they wanted to feed us with the spoon and look so-called "moral." Having said that, the series was done very well, and the main character is played very well. It’s just watered down, reminding me of the days when TV was much less courageous (and maybe that’s exactly where we’re headed). I recommend watching it for anyone who isn’t as fascinated by the twisted mind, the macabre, or the criminology behind it, and would rather see a good crime/police drama that includes a very interesting case served as a kind of side dish with a great main actor. If you are interested in serial killers and that world, just take into account that it’s not the focus of the story. See more Michael B Nov 9 The story and acting was phenomenal. I cried when the Rob Piest story aired (on a later episode). At least we found out what happened to that poor kid. The young actor was amazing! All the victims names should be remembered. See more Kashgar A Nov 9 Honestly one of the most harrowing and distressing things I’ve ever seen. Each episode takes time to honour and bring back to life one or more of the victims. Every actor does immense justice to their role. It actually hurts my heart to watch. See more Avindu G Nov 7 It's often the shock and awe that attracts an audience to a true crime drama. And we are often introduced one or few criminally insane individuals who appears to be unearthly or abominable. But this series manifests itself into a more eye-opening account of how criminal the negligence and political favouritism was in creating this monster. How our societies have been failing to put basic welfare before personal gains is what turns out to be the real serial murderer at the conclusion of this documentary. See more Nov 7 Absolutely riveting from the very first episode. Every actor involved so far (two episodes in) has been top tier. Thoroughly impressed. See more Read all reviews
Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy — Limited Series

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Episodes

Episode 1 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Ten Days After teenager Robert Piest disappears on his mother's birthday, Des Plaines Police Department officers track, interrogate and tail the contractor Piest was last seen with -- John Wayne Gacy. Details Episode 2 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Johnny Officers excavate the crawl space beneath John Wayne Gacy's home; Gacy shows Amirante, Kunkle and Kozenczak where he disposed of Rob's body; Johnny Szyc and his best friend, Lynn, venture into Uptown. Details Episode 3 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Samuel and Randy The media circus begins; Amirante questions whether defending Gacy is the right choice; the Piests cope with the reality of what Gacy did to Rob; Sam Stapleton and Randy Reffett navigate boyhood in Uptown. Details Episode 4 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Billy A psychiatrist interviews Gacy, revealing disturbing details about his past; Tovar and Kozenczak confront the dark truths of the systemic failures that allowed Gacy to kill for so long; a love story unfolds between Billy Kindred and Maryjane. Details Episode 5 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Billy and Dale A blizzard buries Chicago; Kozenczak tracks down Gacy's surviving victims; Kunkle and Kozenczak attempt to break Gacy's accomplice, David Cram; Billy Carroll introduces Dale Landingin to the lucrative, but sometimes dangerous world of sex work. Details Episode 6 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Tim, John and Rob In the past, an inebriated Gacy confesses to Sam the ways he groomed, sexually assaulted, tortured and killed countless boys and young men. Details Episode 7 Aired Oct 16, 2025 David Kunkle and Sam are knee-deep in Gacy's trial; Tovar volunteers to drive Gacy to and from court, attempting to compel him to come clean about how many he killed; the disturbing tale of how Gacy befriended and groomed David Cram is revealed. Details Episode 8 Aired Oct 16, 2025 Jeffrey The life of Jeffrey Rignall, one of Gacy's few surviving victims, is chronicled; Gacy's execution day causes massive protests and reunions as victims' family members and those who worked the case seek closure; Amirante tries to move on. Details

Season Info

Director
Maggie Kiley, Bille Woodruff, Larysa Kondracki, Patrick Macmanus, Ashley Michel Hoban
Executive Producer
Patrick Macmanus, Noah Oppenheim, Liz Cole, Ashley Michel Hoban, Ahmadu Garba, Kelly Funke
Screenwriter
Gregory Locklear, Matthew White, Ashley Michel Hoban, Ahmadu Garba, Sebastian Rea, Patrick Macmanus, Larysa Kondracki
Network
Peacock
Genre
Crime, Drama
Original Language
English
Release Date
Oct 16, 2025
Watch now on