A Battle of Wits

Audience Reviews

View More

camille l 01/31/2014 A Battle of Wits est un bon film dans la mesure ou Jacob Cheung parvient parfaitement a faire oublier ses abominables SFX et a orchestrer des scenes de batailles visuellement reussies. Mais a part Andy Lau et Fan Bingbing, les acteurs sont moyens et l'histoire ne passionnera que les inities a l'histoire de la Chine antique et les fans de film de guerre. Pour ceux qui n'en font pas partie, le film semblera un peu long (20 minutes en moins n'auraient pas ete de refus). See more 04/18/2013 Most of the movie is 3-3.5 stars, however by the end it's really taken you on an original, high quality ride. It's a little slow at times but that's fine because it's a realistic movie here. A few of the cg shots are distractingly flawed, but the movie as a whole has a great look. The non-fantasy action is pretty interesting and the philosophy of the Mozi is fantastically interesting and amazing to research. For the movie though, I'm comfortable leaving it at a very strong 4.0. See more ma'ark t 03/02/2013 The highlight of this movie is the military strategy. There is a deeper message here than just warfare as well. The plot has some interesting twists but perhaps unnecessary so as well. Not as good as 'Red Cliff'. See more 12/23/2012 Kein Martialarts-Film aber eben doch sehr abgehakt in der Erzählweise See more 11/01/2012 When a city state comes under siege by a conquering army commanded by a celebrated strategist, they meet their match in the form of a pacifist warrior dispatched by a friendly nation to aid their allies. With Andy Lau as its star and Jacob Cheung, the action director of Hero, at the helm you expect something pretty spectacular from Battle Of Wits, but despite its epic scale and inventive battle sequences it seems more interested in lecturing the viewer on the dubious morality of warfare than anything else. This means that Cheung spends at least as much time and energy on pseudo intellectual and rather naive waffle as playing to his strengths so that even when visual spectacle and action comes to the fore it's not long before it's interrupted for yet another ham-fisted speech to remind us that "killing is bad". It does have its moments but Cheung confuses sentimentality and manipulation for drama and the characters never feel like real people; just ciphers to get his rather clumsy point across. Some may find the battle sequences worth the rather long winded effort, but Red Cliff did something very similar and did it a lot better. See more 12/19/2011 A rather good movie, all in all, particularly the series of siege tactics - pretty true to the period. Andy Lau did a good job in delivering the pacifist consultant that is the protagonist of the movie. The ending is a little sad, but necessary for wars aren't "pretty" and "perky" and should not be "neat". Too many Hollywood productions are just that way and thus, unrealistic. See more Read all reviews

A Battle of Wits

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW