Thomas and the Magic Railroad

Audience Reviews

View All (259)

Audience Member It's a good children's movie, which is the intended audience, I feel too many people treat this movie as seriously as a national emergency, every child I've seen watch this has absolutely loved it, ergo five stars Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 07/10/25 Full Review Julian V I Don't hate this movie even thought it is not great like they deleted the scene where the villain who was on top on diesel ten was removed but they forgot to remove him when they enter the tunnel this movie should have been better Rated 3/5 Stars •  Rated 3 out of 5 stars 06/02/25 Full Review Nelson M 🚂🚂🚂🚂🚂🚂🚂♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 03/06/25 Full Review Matthew D Just because it's a Kids movie does not mean it's a good movie 😡. Rated 0.5/5 Stars •  Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars 03/11/25 Full Review Mr A One of a Kind and Unique Thomas Production. Since I created the slogan "World of Wonder and Colorful Creativity" to the Thomas 📺 Series, it would fit for this 🎥 also. I can imagine myself watching it in the theater. An interesting fact is that Thomas' name appears in the opening credits which say "Thomas the Tank Engine". Another interesting fact is that Alec Baldwin physically appears in this 🎥 and he's the narrator for seasons 5 and 6 of the Thomas 📺 Series. I discovered the 🎥 in third or fourth grade. This movie is unique as it takes place on the fictional Island of Sodor and the real human world AKA Shining Time and Muffle 🗻. There are some disappointments to this 🎥. For example, Edward doesn't appear in the 🎥. Lots of fans such as myself wonder why Edward is not in the 🎥. I found out from the Thomas Encyclopedia that according to Phil Fherle, there wasn't enough screen time and opportunity to utilize him that added real value to the 🎥. I personally believe that there was a possibility of an opportunity and screen time for Edward to add value to this Special Thomas Production. If Edward were to take another engine's place in this 🎥, he should take Gordon's place. I like Edward better than Gordon as he's nicer to Thomas and that he's also blue like Thomas. I especially dislike Gordon when he made fun of Thomas for his size making both Thomas the Tank Engine and myself 😡. Gordon is not a bad engine but he can sometimes get on your nerves. However, if Edward were in the 🎥, I'm certain he'd be the voice of reason for the engines and he'll likely stand up for Thomas when James would be the one picking on our favorite blue tank engine. If me and my friend Louis were to rewrite the movie, we'd have Edward take Gordon's place and have Gordon take Sir Topham Hatt on his holiday while Edward stays on Sodor to help out Thomas and the other engines. Also, Thomas says that little engines can do big things and he's right. I remember Thomas saying "Little Engines Can Do Big Things, especially when they have nice blue paint like me" which is my favorite quote from this 🎥. Little engines can indeed do big things and Thomas does indeed have nice blue paint. Another detail about this 🎥 I find odd is that James and Percy are voiced by female actors considering that they're male engines. However, I admire the promo images of Thomas and the Magic Railroad. Thomas' shade of blue paint looks very distinguishing and splendid in both the 🎥 and the images. This movie also makes Thomas unique in a way we've never seen before. Thomas is known to be the first and only engine from Sodor who traveled through magic portals which are the magic buffers that lead through the magic railway to Muffle 🗻 and back to Sodor again. Another interesting fact about this movie is that Thomas and Lady form a friendship and I think Thomas is the first engine to interact with her and to be her friend which also makes him unique. That'll teach Gordon not to belittle Thomas or anyone else. One more detail that I find interesting is that Mara Wilson who played the title role in 1996's Matilda is in this movie. Despite this 🎥 being a box office failure, I still love it and if I were in this 🎥, I'd love to travel on board Thomas just like Mr Conductor and Lily did. Id travel on both Thomas and Percy. Even though Edward is not in this 🎥, I'm glad Percy's in it. Also, you can't have a Thomas the Tank Engine 🎥 without Thomas the famous blue tank engine himself as he's the 🌟 of the show so I'm glad Thomas starred in this 🎥. This movie is currently free on YouTube and Tubi so don't miss out. This is a Unique Thomas Production and always will be. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 02/13/25 Full Review Kevin P I can't call it good (even as a little kid, I remember being shouting at the screen "THAT'S NOT SIR TOPPENHAT!" when Alec Baldwin showed up as the train conductor). But there's enough goofy cheesy charm and a pretty imaginative and memorable climax to say it might be worth a watch if you're feeling nostalgic and need to watch something with your kids. Rated 2.5/5 Stars •  Rated 2.5 out of 5 stars 01/30/25 Full Review Read all reviews

Thomas and the Magic Railroad

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now