Season 2 – Our Flag Means Death

Audience Reviews

View More

Andy H @Dwalrus 1d If you want to watch a show where perhaps the historically most feared pirate in history, Blackbeard, shaves his beard, tells a captain of another crew he loves him and then gently kisses him on the lips, then this is the Hollywood pirate fiction you want. As for me… no thanks See more Sonja D @the_nerdpit Jul 3 laugh-out-loud funny, wholesome, a ton of heart, heartbreaking, weird and unhinged. this show’s only fault is that it only has two seasons. See more Annie F @Annxw May 14 I have quite a few issues with this season, especially when it comes to the number of new characters and plotlines introduced in such a short amount of time. It makes the story feel rushed and full of loose ends, while also pulling focus away from what truly mattered. Overall, I also feel like a lot of the silliness that made the first season so special gets lost here. This season is far heavier emotionally and considerably less fun to watch than the first one was. Still, I’m happy with the ending Ed and Stede received. They deserve to ive in peace. See more Ellis Y @RT74260769 Nov 2 So sad till the end wrapped up perfectly even with the cancellation 👌 See more William T @TruthTortoise Aug 3 Is it just me, or did The Swede get like super hot? See more Aye E @RT43717499 05/22/2025 I'm on the fence about this season. It felt like it was made by a different team. There was the quality production from the first season and the characters we love, and great performances. It's inevitable at the conclusion of S1 that there be some darkness. But the tone is so shifted it might as well be another show. I had high hopes of the quality of S1 being continued, but it seems the ship veered off course, too influenced by fan theories, and it overall felt like it was pandering to fans and not staying true to a solid vision, not even from season to season but from episode to episode. The cut budget just neutered any well-paced story telling, just a marathon of cramming ideas in. The music choices and how it was used compared to S1 was inconsistent and not as well crafted. Character story lines from S1 were just dropped. They traumatized a character and treated it like a comic punchline, which made it hard to watch this beloved character in S2. The anachronistic elements which felt slightly more balanced with the history that inspired the show in S1 have all but taken over and sent this careening into a hot mess. See more Read all reviews

Our Flag Means Death — Season 2

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING