Your Christmas or Mine 2

2023

1h 41m

Holiday

Comedy

List

50%

8 Reviews

Tomatometer

43%

Fewer than 50 Ratings

Audience Score

It’s the most wonderful time of the year … but will it be for James and Hayley? James’ father has invited the Taylors to spend Christmas in a luxury ski resort in the Austrian Alps, so they can meet his new American girlfriend. However, Hayley’s dad Geoff insisted on handling his family’s side of the booking and something clearly got lost in translation. After a mix-up with transport at the airport, the two tribes end up at each other’s accommodations, on different sides of a valley and opposite ends of the Tripadvisor ratings scale. Can Hayley and James' relationship survive another turbulent family Christmas, or has their future together gone off-piste?

Read More

Read Less

Watch on Prime Video

Stream Now

Prime Video

Watch Your Christmas or Mine 2 with a subscription on Prime Video.

Chas J

So bad! Hayley and her family are not charming and endearing as they were in the first movie, instead they're obnoxious, annoying and repugnant. The setup and plot of the movie is bad, even for a Christmas movie (which I'm a huge fan of) and it's not long before you're routing for James and Hayley to break up, just get her and her family off the screen. Sucks even more because the first movie was quite good

Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars

12/25/23

Full Review

Jana R

I honestly quite enjoyed the first one, but this sequel... honestly?! The characters become mostly unlikable and immature, the ending is unforgettable and nonsensical and the drama feels staged. Also, as a North European, the whole cliched set up is painful to watch (even for a christmas romcom). Some scenes reminded of the first movie, with a certain charm and familiar humour... unfortunately that didn't convince me though.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

12/23/23

Full Review

Gorptholemew T

🍀 4.0/10 This is such an unintentionally funny movie. I can't the tone is so bad oh my god I just can't pls it's actually fun in a way but so weird. It lacks the spirit A super played out and predictable. Grade C

Rated 2 out of 5 stars

12/23/23

Full Review

Casey D

I mean if you love the first one this one will not disappoint. Great acting all around and the plot is a little ridiculous but good set pieces, solid jokes, the dad from the girls family is a gem, and then the grandpas words of wisdom at the end is a chefs kiss. Not a great movie but a solid sequel and good enough for Christmas though it does deserve to be rated lower than the first.

Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars

12/19/23

Full Review

R 9

It has an issue or two, but for the majority: a good watch. 'Your Christmas or Mine 2' doesn't improve upon its predecessor, it is compartively much weaker, but there are still some amusing moments in there, as well as a solid amount of festive vibes. The change of scenary concerned me early on in terms of how the film would turn out, but turn out well it does in fairness. Cast-wise it's pleasant, those onscreen are the movie's best feature in my opinion. Asa Butterfield and Cora Kirk are a suitable pairing, I mentioned in my review of the original that they didn't appear much together due to the plot but that isn't the case for the most part here. Those in support are swell, including Daniel Mays, Angela Griffin and David Bradley. Ram John Holder doesn't have much to do, though does have a very nice scene with Kirk late on. Jane Krakowski, meanwhile, is a positive addition. One, somewhat minor, issue I did have is the overdramatized plot device near the end. It goes from an overally happy story to all of a sudden becoming a soap opera, as the characters of Butterfield and Kirk hit major drama. It's so over the top, the film doesn't earn the sort of emotional beat that it was trying to portray. It didn't hit, but thankfully wraps up sharpish-ish. That aside, it's a film I'd recommend - especially if you like the first flick, obvs.

Rated 3 out of 5 stars

12/17/23

Full Review

Nina

It was an pretty good Christmas movie. Plot was cheesy but fun. The most annoying thing about it and why I'm only giving two stars is the fact that the movie said that Krampus is an Christmas thing. The movie takes place around Christmas but Krampus belongs to a different Christian Holliday around the 5th of December and has nothing to do with Christmas. This mistake could have been easily avoided by a little research. I expected more from a movie on Amazon Prime.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars

12/12/23

Full Review

Read all reviews

Post a rating

Jim O'Hanlon

Director

Asa Butterfield

James

Cora Kirk

Hayley

Angela Griffin

Kath

Natalie Gumede

Kaye

Daniel Mays

Geoff

Show Less Cast & Crew

Show More Cast & Crew

25%

95%

It's a Wonderful Binge

64%

92%

Cup of Cheer

TRAILER

for Cup of Cheer

0%

38%

Christmas Survival

100%

70%

Christmess

TRAILER

for Christmess

75%

62%

Hollidaysburg

Discover more movies and TV shows.

View More

View more photos

Helen O'Hara

Empire Magazine

The set-up is not as elegant as that of the first film, so this feels more forced and the humour more familiar. Still, the performances are winning and the setting appropriately seasonal, so it might do for the holidays.

Rated: 2/5

Dec 14, 2023

Full Review

Cath Clarke

Guardian

Instantly forgettable.

Rated: 2/5

Dec 5, 2023

Full Review

Stefan Pape

Common Sense Media

Your Christmas or Mine 2 tries to expand on the original premise and in turn loses sight of what made the first film so appealing.

Jan 10, 2024

Full Review

Raven Brunner

Decider

With a sprinkle of mischief and heartbreak, Your Christmas or Mine 2 is a standout Christmas movie that doesn’t sacrifice quality and storytelling for festival cheer.

Dec 8, 2023

Full Review

Amanda Guarragi

Ready Steady Cut

Your Christmas or Mine 2 is a sweet film that is centered on young love and the struggle to integrate two families that normally wouldn’t work well together because of their mentalities.

Rated: 3/5

Dec 8, 2023

Full Review

Gissane Sophia

Marvelous Geeks Media

Prime Video’s Your Christmas or Mine 2 is a worthy follow-up full of hijinks, thoughtfully formulated misunderstandings, and the kind of holiday humor that works due to a well-written screenplay and a charming cast.

Dec 8, 2023

Full Review

Read all reviews

Synopsis

It’s the most wonderful time of the year … but will it be for James and Hayley? James’ father has invited the Taylors to spend Christmas in a luxury ski resort in the Austrian Alps, so they can meet his new American girlfriend. However, Hayley’s dad Geoff insisted on handling his family’s side of the booking and something clearly got lost in translation. After a mix-up with transport at the airport, the two tribes end up at each other’s accommodations, on different sides of a valley and opposite ends of the Tripadvisor ratings scale. Can Hayley and James' relationship survive another turbulent family Christmas, or has their future together gone off-piste?

Director: Jim O'Hanlon
Producer: James De Frond, Kris Thykier, Tom Parry, Damian Keogh
Screenwriter: Tom Parry
Distributor: Amazon Studios
Production Co: Shiny Button Productions, Mighty Pebble Pictures, The Story Collective
Genre: Holiday, Comedy
Original Language: English (United Kingdom)
Release Date (Streaming): Dec 8, 2023
Runtime: 1h 41m

Most Popular at Home Now