A Silence

Audience Reviews

View All (4)

Cinephile B The first part was a bit slow, although it was necessary to introduce the viewer to the family's daily life. I enjoyed watching it, it's a good film, it's always good to address these difficult issues for society. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 06/19/25 Full Review Heidi F Unbelievably slow. The camera lingers too long on a particular shot: while Astrid is driving, Raphael in a nightclub or brooding, for example, when it could have been done in half the time. None of the characters are likeable, although the leads play their roles well. Raphael’s adoption is never explained although it’s clear he isn’t their natural son - why did he have to be adopted? The plot takes forever to get to the point and the ending is unresolved. Can’t understand the high ratings but maybe people think because it’s French it’s automatically good. I certainly didn’t. Rated 1/5 Stars •  Rated 1 out of 5 stars 02/01/25 Full Review Julia S Without a doubt A Silence is a challenging film to watch. Much of it is shot in the dark. The opening scenes of Astrid, shot in extreme close-up, driving through dark gloomy streets, takes us on a journey into a family she works hard to hold together. Director Joachim Lafosse has brought an important subject matter to the cinema, looking at it from Astrid’s POV. A clever device that drags the audience into the murky depths of child abuse, and the lengths family members will go the hide the truth, not only from each other, but from their community. Such are their secrets they seemingly had no friends call or visit. Had they cut themselves off from everyone from fear of being found out? Having worked in this area and with skin in the game, finding the truth of what really happens is difficult. Lafosse cleverly leads the audience on the individual family members journey as they are questioned by the police, and question each other about what they knew, or didn’t know, when, how, why. He leaves questions unanswered leaving it up to the audience to come to their own conclusions. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 07/08/24 Full Review Steve P Joachim Lafosse's A Silence is a slow-burning drama about a family where the unspoken hangs heavy in the air, threatening to suffocate its characters. We meet the Schaars—a wealthy couple, Astrid (Emmanuelle Devos) and François (Daniel Auteuil), living a seemingly idyllic life with their adopted son Raphaël (Matthieu Galloux). But cracks soon begin to show, hinting at a dark secret lurking beneath the surface. Lafosse masterfully ratchets up the tension, drip-feeding us information without ever resorting to melodrama. The film feels distinctly European, its focus on domestic turmoil reminiscent of Michael Haneke's work. However, Lafosse injects a dose of emotional vulnerability missing from Haneke's clinical approach. We see the toll the silence takes on Astrid, her facade of composure crumbling as the truth threatens to unravel. Devos delivers a powerhouse performance, her eyes conveying a lifetime of unspoken pain. Auteuil portrays François with a quiet intensity, his character haunted by past choices. Even newcomer Galloux holds his own, capturing the confusion and anger of a teenager grappling with a fractured family. While the acting is superb, the pacing can slow at times. Long, lingering shots showcase the opulent surroundings that feel increasingly like a gilded cage for the characters. The score is sparse, adding to the film's overall sense of unease. The muted color palette reflects the emotional state of the characters, with pops of color only highlighting their isolation. Lafosse utilizes silence to great effect, letting the characters' unspoken words speak volumes. A Silence isn't an easy watch. It tackles complex themes of guilt, forgiveness, and the enduring power of the past. However, its raw portrayal of family dysfunction and the performances of its central trio make it a compelling, if uncomfortable, watch. If you're looking for a fast-paced thriller, look elsewhere. But for those who appreciate slow-burn dramas that linger long after watching the movie, A Silence is a haunting and thought-provoking film. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 07/03/24 Full Review Read all reviews

A Silence

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW