The Big House

Audience Reviews

View All (24) audience reviews

Mark B There have been so many big-budget prison films and standout series like HBO's Oz, that it's hard to imagine a time when these stories were fresh. Even with the one-dimensional characters, the story keeps pace. Two things kept coming into my mind: These are the oldest corrections officers I've ever seen, and I'm wondering why they cast two nearly identical actors (Chester Morris and Robert Montgomery) as two of leads. In the crappy, 480p version that I watched, I truly had a difficult time telling which was which. #454 in my "watch ever BP nominated film" bucket list. Rated 3/5 Stars •  Rated 3 out of 5 stars 01/14/25 Full Review ChrisCSH H The big house is a film that was way ahead of its time this early Academy award best picture nominee showing the inner workings of a prison and the mundane, and shocking every day tasks. The direction by George W Hill was incredibly shot along with magnificent acting of Wallace Berry, and the climax of the film will leave many people shocked. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 09/09/24 Full Review Louisa E I loved Beery in this movie. I thought his character and acting was great. The cinematography was fantastic. What bothered me about this movie was the pace (I felt it was a bit too slow), and the whole sister romance thing. I read in the trivia of the movie that the original version had it as the goody-two-shoes' wife. That would have been much more interesting and realistic. I guess I also didn't like that they basically made it seem that ratting out the prisoner's escape plans was a bad thing. It just felt a bit disjointed for me but had some wonderful elements. 6.75/10 Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 05/08/23 Full Review Audience Member As one of the first prison movies, this inspired others in this genre. This early example of prison melodrama is still entertaining. This is still good, hard-bitten stuff with one of Beery's best tough guy roles. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 02/08/23 Full Review steve d A erly prison film that somehow is still effective. Rated 3/5 Stars •  Rated 3 out of 5 stars 03/30/23 Full Review Audience Member Prison films from this era tend to serve as social dramas hoping to be Oscar bait that involve an innocent man trapped inside a prison system where he is mistreated before escaping and falling in love with a nice girl. This film had many similarities to the later I Am a Fugitive From a Chain Gang (1932) but it tried to expand the scope of the story with many supporting characters and a little more moral complexity than that film. I found myself liking the film even as I had low expectations for it and due to it's brief running time and some surprisingly involving conflicts I think this earned the critical acclaim it received at the time. Kent, Robert Montgomery, is imprisoned due to drunk driving charges and believes himself to be innocent but he finds himself struggling to fit in at an overcrowded prison. He is roommates with the violent, mercurial Butch, Wallace Beery, and the friendly, fatherly Morgan, Robert Montgomery, but both are members of a clique established in the prison that Kent cannot break into. Kent decides to become a stool pigeon to try to get out of prison early and when Morgan is to receive parole early for good behavior he plants a knife in his bed and has him sent to solitary confinement. When Morgan gets out he fakes an illness and escapes, finding Kent's sister Anne, Leila Hyams, and falling in love with her before he is found and taken back to the prison. Butch has been planning a mass prison escape while Morgan is away and when he arrives back at the prison suspicion is directed his way. He tries to warn the prison guards of the conflict that will arise but they do not listen to him and violence breaks out. One of the major issues with the film is the image quality as unlike other notable films from this era it does not appear to have been restored and so it appears blurry throughout. The cinematographer also appears to have done a poor job of framing as actors will regularly have the tops of their heads cut off or bounce in and out of frame. This occasionally took me out of the film as it was hard to make out what was occurring at some points and at many points where Morris was delivering a dramatic line of dialogue I suddenly could not make out his eyes. This also took away from the set design and cinematography in place as there were some impressive shots, such as the tracking shots of the prisoners passing guns back and forth, that were compromised by the fuzzy image. Here's for hoping that this film does receive some sort of restoration soon as I would like to see some of the imagery in the film clearly. The film also includes an unnecessary interlude in which Morgan escapes from prison and falls in love. This was entirely unnecessary as we already supported Morgan and trusted that he was morally in the right so it was not correct to take him out of the prison environment in an attempt to make the audience care about him more. This section of the film takes you out of it as a big part of the tension of prison films is drawn from the inescapability of the situation the men are in and seeing a man go free halfway through stops this tension from existing. Add in the fact that the Morgan, fascinating while in prison, becomes generic when interacting with his equally standard love interest and you have a big old dead weight in the middle of the film. What could have elevated the film was leaving Morgan in prison and having the aftermath of Kent's betrayal dealt with but instead the film takes the easy way out and gives the audience a plot contrivance that feels forced and lacking in excitement or intrigue. The fun of the film comes with the scenes inside the prison as the dynamic between the three roommates is fascinating and the double crossing has some real shock to it. Montgomery is well cast as a less than intelligent villain and Morris proves to be more capable than he appeared in Alibi (1929) while Beery relies on the same old shtick he employed in a lot of his other roles. For people who love the work of these actors this film will be a real treat. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 02/01/23 Full Review Read all reviews

The Big House

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now