Blossoms in the Dust

Audience Reviews

View More

Mark B @SRT102 07/02/2024 Syrupy, Melodramatic, and really without any redeeming qualities. I have to remember that in 1941, a COLOR film, with an all-star cast, a huge wardrobe budget, expansive production design, and state-of-the-art cinematography (the crane shot following Greer Garson up the stairs would be impressive today) was enough to get a Best Picture nod. Took me a while to find this one as a stream -- wasn't really worth the effort. Glad it's over. #447 films remaining on my "See all BP Nominees" Bucket List. *added later: Didn't realize it was based on a real person. Makes it a little more tolerable. See more 02/02/2021 I really enjoyed this movie, Everyone in the movie played their part very well. My only upsetting thing about the movie was some awful music at certain times in the movie. the lady who ran the orphans home had an african american man and woman who worked for her helping take care of the children. And in several scenes (that were not comedy scenes) when one of the black actors came in the scene they started playing awful banjo music like you might see in a movie about slavery. The people were not servants, they were not playing comedic characters and i found it very offensive. I cant believe greer garsen or any of the other prominent actors didnt protest till they removed that awful out of place music. See more Steve D @RT35616104 07/22/2020 Shameless tearjerker with little to recommend. See more 11/30/2019 I was not alive in the 1940s but I imagine that by the mid-1940s I would have Greer Garson fatigue as her various star vehicles in which she played the exact same character, noble, supportive, resilient and above all respectable, offered very little in the way of interest. This was a film made right before she peaked with the World War II propaganda film Mrs. Miniver (1942) but it did a lot to establish her persona and set her off on a streak of Academy Award nominations that was not to end until 1945. I am not a fan of her persona and because her supposed charms were clearly meant to carry the film I recognized it's weaknesses more easily and was left disappointed at the end of the film despite my low expectations of it from the outset. Wealthy Wisconsinite Edna Kahly, Greer Garson, plans to marry Damon McPherson, John Eldredge, but falls in love with the impetuous Texan cashier Sam Gladney, and chooses to leave behind all that she has known to be with him. She is devastated when her adopted sister Charlotte, Marsha Hunt, who had planned to marry on the same day as her commits suicide as a result of her illegitimacy being revealed by her future mother in law. Edna faces another trial when her child Sammy, Richard Nichols, dies after only a year but she finds a way to emotionally fulfill herself in the absence of children by taking in abandoned and unwanted children. After Gladney loses his job the couple are forced to relocate and in Fort Worth, Texas he finds employment and she opens a home for unwanted and illegitimate children. She becomes very close to the children she takes in, especially the crippled Tony, Pat Barker, and after bridling at a story similar to that of her sister's she launches a successful campaign to have illegitimacy removed from birth certificates. The big issue with the film was in it's structure as it is one of those films where things just happen with no real connective tissue and the film lands at an expected but abrupt ending. The amount of tragedy that this woman faces is probably meant to make the film an effective tearjerker as the pain piles on and yet she keeps going. Unfortunately each of these horribly depressing occurrences is glossed over and it was unrealistic to believe that a woman would recover from the death of her child so quickly or nobly stand by as her husband dies. While this would based on a true story it was a largely fictionalized version of her life and I tend to believe that she would not have bounced back from all the tragedy in her life so quickly. She was probably a deeply damaged woman who struggled to repress her emotions and retained much of the anger and resentment she felt from her youth. Another way in which the film is not helped is in Garson's performance as she is too glamorous and emotionally distant for an audience to believe as a woman facing so much stress. There are long periods in which the film will simply stop to admire Garson's face and they were uncomfortable for me as in the same scenes we are asked to believe that this woman is caring for several children every day. The film never really shows us any of the difficulties that would occur in the day to day life of this woman as we only see her tucking in individual children and appearing mildly concerned while sipping tea. Garson spends most of her time giving those glib smiles that the camera seems to adore so much. She is let down in part by the fact that the film will often cut away from her emotional reactions to horrific events and the jump into another scene in which she has a sickly smile plastered to her face. Even in these moments I think she could have given something more as there was something artificial about her portrayal that she never quite got over and it was hard to swallow her inert characterization. Often listed among the worst films nominated for Best Picture this is a film that earns it's reputation as a real failure. See more ashley h @ashleyhobgood87 04/23/2017 Blossoms in the Dust is a decent film. It is about Edna who marries Texan Sam Gladney, an operator of a wheat mill. Greer Garson and Walter Pidgeon give good performances. The screenplay is a little slow in places. Mervyn LeRoy did an alright job directing this movie. I liked this motion picture because of the drama and romance. See more 02/13/2014 This is a wonderful and true story, about an amazing woman. you will watch it more than once. See more Read all reviews

Blossoms in the Dust

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

Most Popular at Home Now