Me and Earl and the Dying Girl

Audience Reviews

View More (1000+)

ryan y I've still in middle of watching it and I've seen both good and bad reviews. But I am hooked ! The actors, the performances,the writing spot on amazing. Not what I was expecting. the choreography is also very good..it adds to film in its own way.mix of known actors and fresh faces. Don't expect typical young person who has cancer flick and you'll love it ....or not. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 08/03/25 Full Review TheMovieSearch R I finally watched Me and Earl and the Dying Girl, available on Disney+ through the Hulu bundle, after putting it off for some time. The premise is immediately compelling: a high school student, Greg, is reluctantly forced by his mother to befriend Rachel, a classmate recently diagnosed with leukemia. With his filmmaking partner and longtime friend Earl at his side, Greg navigates this awkward new friendship, which promises both emotional depth and coming-of-age insights. At first glance, the setup hints at a heartfelt story centered on Rachel’s journey as a young girl confronting a life-threatening illness. Yet, the film quickly pivots away from her perspective and instead focuses almost entirely on Greg. While Greg’s awkward humor and self-conscious narration provide some comic relief, they overshadow Rachel’s experiences, leaving the audience with a sense that the emotional core of the story is missing. The “dying girl” of the title becomes secondary, which creates a disconnect between expectation and reality. The performances are mixed. Thomas Mann, who plays Greg, brings a believable awkwardness and charm, embodying the stereotypical overthinking, socially anxious teen. RJ Cyler, as Earl, provides solid support, though his character is mostly a sounding board for Greg’s internal monologue rather than a fully realized individual. Olivia Cooke’s Rachel is competent and sympathetic, but the script affords her very little room to shine. Her emotional journey, which should have been the heart of the film, is underdeveloped, leaving her as more of a plot device than a fully fleshed-out character. Visually, the film is inventive. The filmmakers employ unique stylistic flourishes, including animated sequences and meta-commentary, to inject energy and humor into a narrative that could easily have become heavy-handed. Some of these moments are clever and memorable, showcasing the filmmakers’ creativity and ambition. Yet, stylistic flair can only go so far: when the story’s emotional focus is misplaced, these choices sometimes feel like distractions rather than enhancements. The pacing also suffers. The narrative alternates between attempts at humor, awkward social commentary, and emotionally charged scenes, but these transitions rarely feel seamless. Moments that should evoke empathy or reflection are often undercut by quirkiness or deadpan delivery. By the time key emotional beats occur, the audience has often been distanced from Rachel’s perspective, diluting the intended impact. Ultimately, Me and Earl and the Dying Girl is a film that had the potential to be deeply moving, but it misses the mark by prioritizing Greg’s awkward coming-of-age story over Rachel’s very real, very serious journey with cancer. The screenplay is clever in parts, the direction is competent, and the performances are solid, but none of it is enough to anchor the emotional weight the story promises. It’s a film that may appeal to viewers drawn to quirky teen narratives or unconventional storytelling, but for anyone hoping for a genuinely heartfelt portrayal of a young girl’s struggle with illness, it will likely feel disappointing. In conclusion, while the film has its moments of humor and inventive style, it ultimately feels unbalanced and emotionally misdirected. Rachel, the character who should be at the center of this story, is largely sidelined, leaving Greg’s perspective to dominate the narrative. Me and Earl and the Dying Girl is watchable and occasionally engaging, but it is not the emotionally powerful experience that its premise suggests. For those seeking a story that truly honors the challenges and humanity of a young person facing terminal illness, this film falls short. Rated 2.5/5 Stars •  Rated 2.5 out of 5 stars 10/05/25 Full Review Faiz D Funny and touching at the same time. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 05/13/25 Full Review Audience Member Powerful performances by the young actors and a sad story... Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 07/28/25 Full Review Milagros V Hay demasiadas películas de amor adolescente, pero pocas demuestran lo importante que es la amistad en esta edad, todavía lloro al recordar el final. Los diálogos, cinematografía, cada personaje, todo crea una atmósfera que te atrapa y hace que te sientas parte de la historia. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 07/13/25 Full Review The H Was an okay movie, expected it to be a lot better honestly. One thing I liked is that it wasn't the typical love story, fall in love with someone dying trope that so many other sick type movies have done, they were just friends & forced to hang out with each other. Rated 3/5 Stars •  Rated 3 out of 5 stars 02/19/25 Full Review Read all reviews

Me and Earl and the Dying Girl

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now