Murty C
This movie merits watching only for historical reasons. The plot is about a Chinese feudal lord (Mr. Wu) avenging the family dishonor done by an Englishman who seduces Mr. Wu's daughter. The screenplay was interesting until the last quarter of the movie when it became sensationally melodramatic. This is a classic case of "yellowface" - the principal Chinese roles were played by white people! Lon Chaney, as Mr. Wu, is masterful as usual, but it was difficult to believe that Renee Adoree was Chinese and that she was young. The talented and beautiful Anna May Wong is sidelined, playing the part of the daughter's maid. I think it barely became watchable because of Lon Chaney.
Rated 3/5 Stars •
Rated 3 out of 5 stars
06/04/22
Full Review
Audience Member
There are a few things that make this film interesting. You have Lon Chaney, always compelling, dressed up as a rich Chinese man, scowling his way through the film. You have a relationship that develops between Renée Adorée and Ralph Forbes which is forbidden for a couple of reasons: it's 'mixed-race', and she's already had her husband decided by her father. You have the beautiful Anna May Wong, albeit relegated to a smaller role. And you have some pretty nice sets, with circular doors, arched bridges, beautiful furniture, and the like.
On the other hand, you have white actors playing the lead Chinese characters and not passing, with Adorée not only visually not looking the part, but acting poorly on top of it. In one of her early scenes it's as if she thinks she's a marionette. It's such a shame, because there you have the actress who should have gotten the role - Anna May Wong - standing beside her for much of the film. The film also plods along, and even in moments where we're expected to feel tension, lacks the authenticity to deliver. Lastly, it's racist in ways that are about as offensive to Asians as a blackface production from this period are to African-Americans.
There is racism in many forms in films of this time period which one becomes inured too with enough exposure, however, in this film it's especially insidious. You have the blatant forms, one of the worst of which is a Chinese servant idiotically bowing to his white employer and to a fan repeatedly after being told to shut it off. Another is that same white man refusing to have tea with "chinks", and then upon doing so, acting as though the biscuits served were horrible, saying "You Chinese eat the silliest food!" However, what makes the film particularly awful is the portrayal of Chinese customs demanding that a daughter die at the hands of her father because she's been romantically involved with a white man, and then later that the mother of the white man be forced to choose who is to die between him and his sister. Lon Chaney is sinister as Mr. Wu, but the message is undeniably one of cruelty and barbarism - and not just in this particular character, but in the Chinese race as a whole. The "Yellow Peril" is on full display here.
A much better film with suspense coming from a diabolical Chinese character played by a Caucasian is "The Mask of Fu Manchu" (1932), with Boris Karloff and Myrna Loy. That film also played to fear of Asians, but there the evil is confined to over-the-top individuals. Better yet, if you'd like to see a fantastic film with actual Asians cast as Asians and a strong, intelligent beautiful character (Anna May Wong!) getting involved in a 'mixed-race' relationship, watch "Piccadilly" (1929). That one puts 'Mr. Wu' to shame.
Rated 2/5 Stars •
Rated 2 out of 5 stars
01/13/23
Full Review
Audience Member
in this silent u get the 'man of a 1000 faces' times 2
Rated 3/5 Stars •
Rated 3 out of 5 stars
01/21/23
Full Review
Audience Member
Better than most silent dramas. Of course the white man's love interest is a Caucasian actress in Asian make-up, they couldn't allow an inter-racial courtship on screen. Nice cliffhanger at the end - complete with traditional Hollywood ending.
Rated 3.5/5 Stars •
Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars
01/25/23
Full Review
eric b
Naturally, all sorts of warning buzzers go off when you hear of a silent-era film with a white man portraying an Asian (even if the actor is the great Lon Chaney). And sure, there are some uncomfortable moments in "Mr. Wu." Lots of stereotypical talk about the "ancient ways" of these stuffy "Chinks," and there's one especially bad scene where a Chinese servant sees his white employer chasing a storm of papers swirling around a desk and is too dumb to understand that a nearby electric fan is the cause. Come on!
Still, "Mr. Wu" is a stylish tale of tragic romance. Wu's beloved daughter Nang Ping (yes, the actress is also white) is about to enter an arranged marriage, but these traditional plans hit a snag when she encounters a posh Western lad by chance. Soon they're secretly nuzzling in the garden, pantomiming those silly, damp-eyed conversations that silent-movie lovers always have.
When Wu hears of their scandalous courtship, he has to decide whether to punish his daughter as severely as his moral code demands.
"Mr. Wu" is well-directed, and the costumes and furnishings of the noble Wu's estate are lovely. As a bonus for Chaney fans, the actor also portrays a withered grandfather during the opening scenes.
Rated 3/5 Stars •
Rated 3 out of 5 stars
03/31/23
Full Review
Audience Member
This was a little melodramatic silent film this was...but very well made silent film. Lon Chaney Snr was truly the man of 1000 faces and he delivers one of his most extraordinary performances of his silent career.
Chaney was brilliant as the tyrant mad deranged traditional father & his descent to madness just showed the calibre of actor he was.
Also the oriental look of this film was sensational the camera man really got the film looking top notch. Also Mr Wu's daughter played by Anna May Wong gave a terrific supporting performance...very heavy but believable. This is a intense film but an achievement none the less.
Rated 3.5/5 Stars •
Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars
02/21/23
Full Review
Read all reviews
Post a rating
>
