Autumn Sonata

Audience Reviews

View All (362) audience reviews

John A Not as subtle and layered as previous Ingmar Bergman films however this final production (that was made for cinemas) does finally reach the viewer somewhere near the midpoint. Liv & Ingrid are both fairly compelling in this talky and somewhat searing character study. Rated 3/5 Stars •  Rated 3 out of 5 stars 03/09/24 Full Review Jeff M Dysfunctional family drama is my favorite genre of film and television, so a motion picture like this is absolute catnip to me. Ingrid and Liv were born to play mother and daughter, and their extended back and forth is definitive proof that words are more powerful and wounding than any weapon imaginable. It's a fascinating relationship - their reunion at first seems quite conciliatory, but little by little the tension begins to build until the climactic night when years of resentment pour forth like lava from a volcano. It's indeed explosive, but these filmmakers are too smart to go for the expected histrionics. There is very little screaming and pulling of hair and gnashing of teeth - it's more sadness and regret and (possibly?) a little embellishment and exaggeration. Director Bergman and actress Bergman famously had quite the contentious relationship during the making of this movie, but the result was worth the antagonism. Ingrid is quite extraordinary here, and the knowledge that she was ill during the filming only adds to the heartache and pain. Ullmann is her match step by step - she is an actress about whom I've heard many superlatives, but this is my first time seeing her in action. It won't be my last! I'm certain many will find this boring and too talky - I was on the edge of my seat throughout. This definitely ranks among my favorite family dramas of all time. Rated 4.5/5 Stars •  Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars 02/11/24 Full Review Esra Y One of my most favorite Bergman movies. Mother-daughter confrontation scene is so real, so close to my heart I come to tears. Always admired Bergman's ability to understand and tell human emotions, psychology in such genuine way. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 10/26/23 Full Review William L 1978 Tragic Family Drama: "I wonder whether I've lived at all. Is it the same for everybody, or do some people have a greater talent for living than others? Or do some people never live? They just exist." 2022 Millennials/Gen X: "Honestly bro same." Somehow the only collaboration between legendary Swedish director Ingmar Bergman and equally legendary Swedish actress Ingrid Bergman (no relation), Autumn Sonata was not immediately hailed as a masterpiece by contemporary audiences, and it's somewhat understandable why - it combines more active dialogue (abandoning the lingering empty space that the director often used to great effect in the past) with a subjectively restrained visual composition (nearly all of the scenes take place in relatively nondescript Swedish houses). The film relies almost entirely on the dynamic between its two main characters, Ingrid Bergman's Charlotte and Liv Ullmann's Eva, a mother and daughter who gradually revisit the unresolved trauma of their pasts in a way that they had found more convenient to gloss over or forget. The brilliant aspect to their discord is that it feels organic and real while exploring (i.e., an actual conflict) while touching on two characters that are simultaneously flawed yet completely relatable. Charlotte represents personal ambition and self-fulfilment (at the expense of a sense of indifference and selfishness) while Eva is an embodiment of childhood trauma, an existence that didn't ask to be created before being left to fend emotionally for themselves (recognizing the limitations in holding onto the past, but unable to let go). These are characters built on basic human principles and are executed well both in the screenplay and in front of the camera with top-notch performances, and they largely succeed in conveying the principles of basic human weakness and irreconcilable intergenerational differences. My only complaint (if you can call it that) about Autumn Sonata is that it feels very much like a cinematic adaptation of a theatrical play, even though the domestic discord source material doesn't necessitate any grand flourishes (and is likely better for not including any). Overall, still a very good component of the filmography of both Bergmans, which remains thematically sharp as all sincerely human dramas tend to. (4/5) Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 07/07/22 Full Review Audience Member Simply an overwrought and maudlin family drama. Overacted and unconvincing as well as being plain depressing. I got nothing out of watching this. Rated 1/5 Stars •  Rated 1 out of 5 stars 01/28/23 Full Review Audience Member My introduction to Bergman! Let me say, some of the greatest acting I've literally ever seen. However the story is slow and there's not much there… I understand the point but it's just so slow and honestly a little hard to watch. Although, it made me cry. That's good. 4 stars for making it deep enough to allow me to cry. :) Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 02/13/23 Full Review Read all reviews

Autumn Sonata

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now