Liam D
One of the first Hollywood biopics and while it has great performances it's length is way too long and didn't deserve to win Best Picture
Rated 3.5/5 Stars •
Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars
03/31/24
Full Review
Keefe D
If the viewer was to judge Ziegfeld's on his character; financial expertise; friendship to his peers and coworkers; and relationships, he wasn't so great. Ziegfeld's treatment of his friend and financial backer Jack Billings is absolutely reprehensible. The Great Ziegfeld has a bland story and the musical numbers are forgettable. It's 3 hours I'll never get back.
Rated 0.5/5 Stars •
Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars
02/12/23
Full Review
Audience Member
I first heard about William Powell not in the "Thin Man" films, but as the curmudgeonly Doc in the World War II classic "Mister Roberts", also starring Henry Fonda, James Cagney, and Jack Lemmon (in his first Oscar-winning role). By the time that movie came out, Powell was a veteran actor in the final stages of his career ("Mister Roberts" was his final motion picture appearance, followed by a role in a 1969 short film). So, upon the discovery that it was he who starred in the 1936 Best Picture winner, I had to take a look. And now that I have seen "The Great Ziegfeld", I must say that Powell's performance saved this film from what could very easily have been pure Depression-era escapist hoo-ha.
Sure, Luise Rainer took home Best Actress for her melodramatic portrayal of Ziegfeld's melodramatic first wife, Anna Held (To echo a sentiment of a fellow IMDb reviewer of this film, she originated the now-familiar "smiling through the tears" performance that we have seen many times). And Myrna Loy did a fine job as his second wife Billie Burke (you know, Glinda the Good Witch from "The Wizard of Oz"). Throw in some fine performances by Nat Pendleton as The Great Sandow and Virginia Bruce as the talented yet troublesome Audrey Dane, and you have what appears to be a fairly well-done biographical film about Florenz Ziegfeld, right?
Ah, but this is a movie about Florenz Ziegfeld, and in movies about Florenz Ziegfeld, you need to showcase some musical numbers and how he would have staged them. Don't get me wrong, the musical numbers in this movie feature some of the best choreography and staging of the Depression Era, with stages that moved in and out (in sections and all at once), dogs that stayed at their marks for over two minutes as women danced around (and over!) them, and the costumes! Oh, the costumes! How those women paraded around in some of those things with smiles on their faces is beyond me!
But over and above that is the infamous "A Pretty Girl Is Like a Melody", which everyone claims was done in a single shot. But if you look more closely, it was really done in two shots; the transition happens at the clown's close-up. Even with two shots (three, if you count the curtain reveal), we are talking about a single continuous production piece that stretches for seven minutes! It is perfectly clear that MGM spared no expense in making this movie. In fact, it cost about as much money to film "Pretty Girl" as it did for Ziegfeld himself to produce one of his Follies!
MGM was notorious for their over-the-top productions during the 1930s, and "The Great Ziegfeld" was no exception. The mentality at the time was that America (and much of the world, for that matter) was caught in the Great Depression, and the public needed movie musicals with bright, cheerful, optimistic, and lavish set pieces to "forget" about their troubles for a couple of hours. And, even though it isn't technically a musical, this film fits that bill. But with a running time of nearly three hours, "The Great Ziegfeld" seems to stall during the lavish musical numbers, making it severely dated by today's standards.
But I have saved the film's saving grace for last, and his name is William Powell! As Ziegfeld, he is both legitimate businessman and snake-oil vendor, devoted husband and father and lecherous womanizer, brilliant showman and luckiest man on Earth! But what makes Ziegfeld fascinating is the ease at which Powell moves from one end of the spectrum to the other in a flash, then back again, especially when playing with (or is it against?) Frank Morgan. As Ziegfeld's rival/nemesis/business partner Jack Billings, Frank Morgan gave us a man who was both flustered by and respectful to Ziegfeld's knack for showmanship.
As a bonus to the film, two people who owed their careers in show business to Florenz Ziegfeld appear as themselves in "The Great Ziegfeld". First up is Fanny Brice, who re-enacts her discovery by and her audition for him. And the legendary Ray Bolger does a wonderful dance number that rivals, if not outdoes, anything he did three years later in "The Wizard of Oz".
So there you have it. This review seems about as long as the movie itself, so I will sum it up like this: "The Great Ziegfeld" is too long and it stalls during the musical numbers, but William Powell and Ray Bolger make it worth watching.
Rated 3/5 Stars •
Rated 3 out of 5 stars
02/08/23
Full Review
Audience Member
This movie is plodding at times. The musical numbers are very long and at times tedious and have nothing to do with the plot of the movie. It seemed like a way to get the runtime to 3 hours and to make sure the Best Picture award was all theirs. They were beautifully shot, wonderfully acted and the costumes were amazing. They were just long. My biggest gripe is the main character. At no time during this film did I ever feel sorry for him nor did I ever cheer for him. He was a con artist of the highest order and that kind of character is just too much for me to care about. I understand why he did these things but they were still under-handed and not becoming of a good protagonist. Great film for its time, definite recommend, especially for the lavish, although long, musical numbers.
Rated 3.5/5 Stars •
Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars
02/06/23
Full Review
Audience Member
Overblown, but fun to watch. Oscar for Best Picture!
Rated 3/5 Stars •
Rated 3 out of 5 stars
04/09/21
Full Review
Audience Member
Only an hour too long. It's like a less compelling version of Yankee Doodle Dandy though admittedly this came first. There is one spectacular musical scene which cost an absolute fortune to make but was worth it as it was the only standout moment in the film. Back in the day this was a high water mark for musicals but more recent appraisals are closer to the mark. This is bloated beyond excuse and is one of the more disappointing best picture academy award winners.
Rated 1.5/5 Stars •
Rated 1.5 out of 5 stars
01/28/23
Full Review
Read all reviews
>
