Darcie J
Every time I watch this movie I pick up more. Very awesome and worth watching multiple times.
Rated 5/5 Stars •
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
01/09/22
Full Review
Little Life S
People need to be so literal with religion SMH. This movie was incredible. Don’t read what it’s about, just start watching it.
Rated 5/5 Stars •
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
02/13/25
Full Review
Peter S
The Shack: A Failed Attempt to Justify Divine Indifference
The Shack is a film that attempts, but ultimately fails, to reconcile the problem of human suffering with the existence of an omnipotent and benevolent God. Cloaked in sentimentality and theological platitudes, the movie offers little more than a shallow, emotionally manipulative justification for divine apathy, which collapses under even the slightest philosophical scrutiny.
At its core, The Shack tells the story of a grieving father, Mack, who is drawn into a mystical encounter with God (depicted as the warm, maternal “Papa”), Jesus, and the Holy Spirit after the brutal murder of his young daughter. The film tries to console viewers with the notion that suffering, regardless of how monstrous, is somehow part of a higher plan—one that we mere mortals are too limited to comprehend. This is a tired defense of theism that has been trotted out for centuries: the suffering of the innocent is a divine mystery, and questioning it is met with a condescending, “You just don’t understand.”
However, let’s examine this “plan” more honestly. Our species has existed for approximately 300,000 years, during which time the average lifespan hovered around 25 years. For most of our existence, human beings suffered gruesome deaths from disease, famine, and predators, long before concepts like morality or salvation ever entered the picture. If we take The Shack at its word, “Papa” allowed humanity to languish in agony for millennia before deciding, only 2,000 years ago, to intervene—not with an end to suffering, not with a cure for disease or the eradication of war, but by sending his son to be tortured and executed as a convoluted act of redemption. According to the film, this is supposed to be an expression of love.
Of course, the movie avoids engaging with these deeper implications. Instead, it embraces a saccharine, feel-good spirituality that serves as a defense mechanism for those unwilling to confront the stark indifference of the universe. We are told that God is neither cruel nor neglectful—just deeply misunderstood. However, what we are really being asked to accept is divine negligence reframed as wisdom. If a human parent displayed the same level of detachment toward their suffering children, we would rightly call them a monster. Yet The Shack expects us to view this divine abandonment as an expression of unconditional love.
The truth is much simpler and far less comforting: the universe does not care because there is no one there to care. God is neither good nor evil—not because he operates on some higher plane of morality, but because he does not exist. Ultimately, what The Shack offers is not an answer to suffering, but a desperate attempt to mask the absence of one. It is a film designed to comfort those who cannot bear the weight of an indifferent cosmos, presenting a pretty lie wrapped in soft lighting and emotional manipulation. For those who refuse to be placated by sentimentality, it serves only as a reminder of religion’s long history of rationalizing the irrational and justifying the unjustifiable.
If you seek a film that truly explores suffering and the absence of meaning with intellectual honesty, The Shack is not it. However, if you are willing to suspend all reason and accept circular theological excuses as profound insights, you may find it deeply moving. But for those of us who reject fairy tales in favor of reality, the film is little more than a hollow, pitiful excuse for the silence of a non-existent God.
Rated 0.5/5 Stars •
Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars
02/12/25
Full Review
Sebeast A
This is a movie you see with your heart not your eyes or intellect.
It is not a religious or historic depiction of the Bible, or a traditional recounting of Christianity. it is an interpretation of grief and pain and injustice and how these things can be viewed through love. In a way the movie proposes that all we perceive as external has to be turned inwards in order to heal.
We must release judgement, hate, anger through forgiveness. Forgiveness of those who have wronged us and forgiveness of ourselves. It is a simple message but a very True message. I liked the way these spiritual forces of the father son and Holy Ghost are depicted. As ver close and personal.
It is sentimental, and kind of manipulative at times but it serves a good purpose if you are ready to receive it.
The movie deals in archetypes, it is not a true recounting of a story, and it hides some pretty deep reflexions in it’s narrative. I specially love the sinking boat and the garden metaphors. They resonated with me, I believe they speak to a universal truth of growth and compassion. A testament to the contribution of Christian philosophy to religious and spiritual discourse.
Sure, organized religion is flawed and there is a lot that is wrong with the world, but that does not detract from this movie’s poignant message.
The disparity in the reviews is simply between those that have succumbed to cinicism and those who choose to see it with an open heart.
As a technical achievement, it’s ok I guess. Nothing out of the ordinary, script and cinematography were fine.
I do, however, believe the movie was made with a lot of love, I think the actors, directors and writers were invested in creating something that would touch viewers on an intimate level and provoque some self reflexión.
I am grateful for it.
Rated 5/5 Stars •
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
02/09/25
Full Review
Tom R
This has to be one of the worst films I've ever watched. The problem was I never believed it. That little girl was murdered and God wanted her father to forgive that serial killer? Bull! If my daughter was murdered I'd want to kill that b***ard. As you would want to if any of your family was murdered. Forgive him? Yes but after he was punished in Hell for 1000 years and only a maybe then. Leave it to God to punish sinners! Absolutely! But God would allow me to help Him judge that Sinner too. The structure of the film was also lacking to me. The second half of this film was much too long. But the last part of the 2nd Act was very very strong. I became very confused as to which character became God the Father. That strong American African? Or that strong man who looked like an Innuit who helped to find the little girls body. And why didn't the Dad find her body at the end of the film? He was allowed to bury her and grieve over her but not the rest of his family. Very unbelievable even though all of that long segment seemed to be a dream sequence.
What I DID like very much was the cinematography, the visual effects, the beautiful locations and all of the actors. Tom Richards
Rated 0.5/5 Stars •
Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars
02/09/25
Full Review
Sparkle C
The poor ratings are so disappointing. So many people have their own selfish understanding of God and Heaven and what he/she should look like when in fact none of us will ever know until by his Grace we get to Heaven. I loved this movie. I’ve watched it at least 6 times and cried everytime. It gives me hope. It makes me feel good and I am grateful for it. I welcome anyone who watches it to let go of your stuck up thoughts and value the message the movie is giving us. God Bless you all.
Rated 5/5 Stars •
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
01/19/25
Full Review
Read all reviews