Winchester '73

Audience Reviews

View More (244)

Keith M OMG!!! This movie is SOOOOOOO over-rated. Watched it based on the reviews on here and was utterly disappointed. Bad script and other than Jimmy Stewart, bad acting. No wonder I had NEVER heard of it. Not worth talking about. Rated 2/5 Stars •  Rated 2 out of 5 stars 08/05/25 Full Review acsdoug D Jimmy Stewart proves he can play a tough gunman in this decent Western. Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 05/20/24 Full Review Alec B At a certain point it stops being about the titular gun and becomes a family tragedy which is exactly when the movie gets interesting. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 02/27/24 Full Review Franky L This is one of my favorite westerns! If you have not watched it, and you are a western film lover, put this on your watch list now. The cast is superb, starring a young Shelly Winters. We remember her from the Poseiden Adventure as Mrs. Rosen, but she was such an awesome actress in her youth. And this is a far cry from Jummy Stewart in his later films where he's the "nice guy." Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 01/18/24 Full Review Isaiah Y Essential viewing for any fans of westerns, partly due to Jimmy Stewart's performance. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 01/05/24 Full Review Matthew B It is possible that if James Stewart had retired in 1949, his reputation as an actor would have been very different. Certainly Stewart felt that Winchester ‘73 had rescued and redefined his career. It opened up the path for a whole range of challenging new roles that were to prove that Stewart was not the limited actor that some people thought he was. When Stewart teamed up with director Anthony Mann to make a western, there was some ridicule in the press about the idea of the actor playing a tough hero. Winchester '73 was certainly not Stewart's first western, but earlier outings such as Destry Rides Again were lighter in tone. However Stewart's dedication to stretching the range of his acting paid off. He practised using a rifle so that he would look more convincing. More importantly he cultivated a stronger personality. The scene where he smashes Dan Duryea on the bar, and brutally twists his arm drew gasps from the audience, and removed any doubts people had about Stewart's ability to be a convincing western hero. Stewart's career was given the fillip it needed, and the presence of Stewart did no harm for Anthony Mann either, a moviemaker who had stylishly directed a number of low budget B-movies, and was now trying to break through into A-movies. This was his second attempt, and a great success. I have said a lot about the impressive acting by James Stewart in an unfamiliar role, but it could be argued that the real hero of this movie is the titular ‘character', the rifle known as the Winchester '73. The movie opens with a shot of the rifle, and ends with a close-up of it. This particular gun is a One of One Thousand grade, an unusually well-made gun that actually was produced by the Winchester Repeating Arms Company, as the movie says. Perhaps it is only in America that a movie could be made which fetishizes a type of gun. As the film opens we see children and even adults gazing in awe at this impressive rifle, and the film ends not when the hero gets the girl, but when the hero gets the gun. However the significance of the gun is not the just the item itself, but its role in the history of the age. As the name of the company suggests, this was a repeating rifle, as opposed to the single-shot guns of old, and it was about to transform the whole nature of military actions. As the opening caption of the movie explains, the gun would appeal to cowman, lawman, peace officer, soldier, and of course the Indians who would be only too glad to get their hands on it. The plot follows two connected strands, as the hero Lin McAdam pursues his brother who is going by the name of Dutch Henry Brown (Stephen McNally). Lin is in pursuit of both the gun, which Brown steals, and of Brown himself, whom Lin wishes to kill to avenge Brown's murder of their father. The gun is only a later grievance. Along the way we take in Wyatt Earp, gun-running and the spirit of Little Bighorn. The movie is certainly no epic, and is not intended to be mounted that way. This is something of a relief. After the 70s it became harder to find westerns that were not long and bloated attempts to present History in the making. In the heyday of westerns, it was recognised that small-scale stories could allow more scope for tight plotting, characterisation and fast pace. Hence Winchester '73 offers only a snapshot of its age, and does not allow the story to be bogged down in solemn attempts to make a constipated epic. The story is certainly contrived to allow historical events to be shoehorned in, but always in a fun way. I wrote a longer appreciation of Winchester '73 on my blog page if you would like to read more: https://themoviescreenscene.wordpress.com/2018/06/01/winchester-73-1950/ Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 09/28/23 Full Review Read all reviews

Winchester '73

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now