Playing for Time

Audience Reviews

View All (16) audience reviews

Chris S Vanessa Redgrave is unbelievably good. She is amazing but the script and story (based on the memoir of a prison camp survivor). Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 06/01/24 Full Review Clara D C Timeless movie, and I come back every once in a while to watch it again. Vanessa Redgrave's performance is beautiful, and so cool to see Christine Baranski in the beginning of her career. Definitely recommend. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 06/09/23 Full Review Max T I come back and watch this film about every year. Vanessa Redgrave's performance blows me away every time. 100% recommend everyone to watch this. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 05/26/23 Full Review Audience Member "Playing for Time" explores the interactions of a group of female Auschwitz inmates who share an uncommon bond – the "privilege" of being inducted into the camp orchestra. At times the film is up to the task in graphically portraying the debasement of the Jews under Nazism, such as the brutal conditions they endure as they are deported to Auschwitz, and the assembly line visuals of naked women being shorn hairless. On the other hand, glaring shortcomings hobble its power to fully immerse the viewer into this realm of the macabre, where the soothing effects of orchestra music facilitate the orderly herding of vast numbers of men, women, and children into Auschwitz's gas chambers. An overarching deficiency, the failure to capture the epic scale of Auschwitz's numbers and all-encompassing savagery, paints the film's atmosphere with a much more benign palette than reality would dictate. This probably should not surprise us, though, since budget constraints often plague movies produced for television. What is more troubling is the inexplicable casting of Vanessa Redgrave in the role of Fania Fenelon, a Parisian cabaret singer of that era, upon whom the movie is based. Forget the fact that Redgraves' physical type is the polar opposite of Fenelon's. What can't be ignored is that Redgraves' singing prowess doesn't even approach the level of talent one would need to be plucked from a labor detail in Auschwitz to fill the solo slot in an orchestra - to sing opera, no less. From its opening scene until the finale, "Playing for Time" showcases the full range of Redgraves' vocal mediocrity as she incessantly regales us with a variety of tunes. The absurdity approaches gas lighting though, as she mesmerizes Dr. Mengele and other Nazi officials while croaking out various Madame Butterfly arias. Kudos to the acting chops of Shirley Knight as Maria Mandel, a high ranking Nazi official and music aficionado. Her apparent rapture during these performances is almost believable. Was Fenelon canonized at some point? I must have missed that because only a saint could have navigated through that abyss with such absolute moral clarity. Her prodigious ego rides roughshod over credibility as she consistently and unabashedly inserts herself as the spiritual guru of her own story. The rest of the orchestra members serve as mere counter points, a troupe of childlike, morally deficient or intellectually lazy minions whom she graces with her pearls. Take, for instance, her inner turmoil after being gifted with a "tainted" link of sausage, procured by the ever pragmatic Marianne, via a "roll in the hay" of sorts with an SS Officer. Rather than showing gratitude, Redgrave proceeds to hold forth about the spiritual consequences collateral to that medium of exchange. We then witness every protracted nuance of Redgrave chewing the scenery while struggling to chew the offending sausage link. Seriously? After being systematically starved for months? The portrayal of the renowned vocalist, Fania Fenelon, by an actress who can barely sing and as a character whose unbridled sanctimoniousness sours our empathy for her, seriously ratchets down the quality of "Playing for Time". In spite of this, the film's thought provoking foray into the "grey zone" that was endemic to Auschwitz, in which the struggle to survive often necessitated some form of collusion with the enemy, provides enough of a counter balance to redeem this film. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 01/15/23 Full Review Audience Member It's a good movie but not amazing. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 01/30/23 Full Review Audience Member i did not know this was based on a true story the movie has not aged too well but is still very good acting was good interesting story some scenes were surprisingly intense some parts felt a bit slow a must watch for those trying to learn about the holocaust Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 02/07/23 Full Review Read all reviews

Playing for Time

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW