The Red Virgin

Audience Reviews

View All (4) audience reviews

Riccardo g The theme of female emancipation, although important, is overexposed and repetitive, giving the feeling that the message is more important than the story. Ultimately, "Hildegart: the Red Virgin" is a work that functions more as an ideological manifesto than as a universal narrative, risking alienating those looking for a less schematic story. Rated 0.5/5 Stars •  Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars 12/18/24 Full Review Joshua G The camerawork is impeccable. The acting is flawless. The score is gorgeous. Well worth watching. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 12/14/24 Full Review Autumn A Najwa Nimri is always so much Najwa. It's impossible not to be amazed by the perfection of her performance. The control she exerts over her face, body, and voice is simply breathtaking. And let's face it, if this actress were playing in the Hollywood leagues, she would already have at least a couple of Oscars. Her ability to convey profound emotions through mere glances and silences elevates the film to a work of art. Indeed, she could carry the entire film on her shoulders, but she is blessed with a supporting cast that is equally brilliant. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 12/09/24 Full Review jaypee m An Overwrought Exercise in Pretension: A Review of Red Virgin Rarely does a film manage to so thoroughly alienate its audience under the guise of profundity as Red Virgin does. Ostensibly an exploration of existential ennui and the human condition, the movie instead revels in a self-aggrandizing cacophony of pseudo-intellectualism, leaving little room for genuine emotional resonance. From its overwrought dialogue to its meandering narrative structure, Red Virgin is an exercise in cinematic vanity. Its deliberate opacity, while ostensibly designed to provoke thought, feels more like an indulgent gambit to obfuscate the film’s lack of substantive insight. Characters pontificate endlessly in sesquipedalian soliloquies that masquerade as profundity but ultimately amount to vapid platitudes. The narrative, bereft of coherence, relies on contrived symbolism so ham-fisted that it borders on parody. The film’s visual aesthetic, often lauded by its admirers, is similarly emblematic of its pretensions. While undeniably sumptuous, the cinematography feels more like an exercise in self-congratulatory artifice than a medium for storytelling. Long, languid shots linger interminably on ostensibly significant objects—a dripping faucet, a flickering lightbulb—offering little in the way of narrative advancement or emotional depth. The result is a stultifying experience that prioritizes style over substance at every turn. What is most galling, however, is the cult of admiration that has inexplicably formed around this cinematic mirage. Many of its so-called “fans” appear less enamored with the film itself than with the intellectual cachet associated with liking it. To praise Red Virgin is, for some, less a matter of genuine appreciation than an act of performative cultural elitism. One cannot help but suspect that many who extol its virtues do so out of a fear of being perceived as philistines, rather than from any authentic engagement with its content. Ultimately, Red Virgin fails not because it is ambitious, but because its ambition is hollow. Its pretensions to intellectualism are belied by its inability to offer any real insights, and its attempts at emotional profundity ring hollow. Far from being a masterpiece, it is a monument to cinematic hubris—a film that mistakes opacity for depth and self-indulgence for art. Rated 0.5/5 Stars •  Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars 12/05/24 Full Review Read all reviews

The Red Virgin

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW