A Dark Song

Audience Reviews

View More (191)

Drew M It's clear the writer was trying to say something meaningful about grief, but the ending felt absurdly forced for a film spending so much time wrapped up in realistic portrayals of a harrowing ritual. If the ending hits for you then the acting, cinematography, are well-done enough that the drawn out conclusion to the ritual feels like a payoff. For me, it felt tonally inconsistent and abrupt, not a natural progression towards an inevitable conclusion or even a well designed subversion of expectations. Rated 2.5/5 Stars •  Rated 2.5 out of 5 stars 09/22/25 Full Review ROY Y "A Dark Song" is less a horror film and more a grueling procedural drama about a spiritual ordeal. It stands apart from its contemporaries by refusing to rely on cheap scares, opting instead for an atmosphere of suffocating dread and a meticulous, almost painful, focus on the mechanics of occult ritual. For the discerning viewer, particularly one versed in theology or psychology, the film offers not entertainment, but a powerful, and potentially perilous, case study. The Authenticity of the Ordeal The film's primary strength is its commitment to process. Based on the real-world Book of Abramelin, the narrative follows Sophia's months-long psychological and physical descent as she and the occultist Joseph prepare for a divine encounter. This is where the film finds its "truth." It authentically portrays the universal archetypes of a spiritual quest: the unwavering discipline required, the crushing isolation, the agonizing periods of doubt and despair, and the slow, painful stripping away of the ego. The film forces the viewer to confront the reality that any genuine spiritual ascent requires a torturous descent into the self. It validates the principle that suffering is not an obstacle to transformation, but the very mechanism of it. The Critical Flaw: Compulsion vs. Surrender Here, however, the film must be viewed with extreme analytical caution. The entire operation is built on a foundation of human will—Sophia's will to contact her deceased son. The ritual is an attempt to compel grace, to treat the divine as a system to be hacked and manipulated for a desired outcome. This is the film's central, and most dangerous, theological error. It presents a path of compulsion rather than surrender. The protagonist's immense suffering is channeled into an act of supreme spiritual pride, not humility. For viewers with a background in traditional faith, this is a critical distinction. The film is a masterful depiction of what happens when the human desire for control is projected onto the divine. It is a journey not towards God's will, but towards the temporary deification of human will. Recommendation: A Viewer's Mandate We recommend "A Dark Song" not as a casual horror film, but as an advanced intellectual and spiritual exercise. It is essential viewing for those who study the intersection of faith, psychology, and the human hunger for meaning. However, we issue this recommendation with a stern mandate: one must protect the mind. Do not watch this film passively. Watch it as an analyst. Deconstruct its theological arguments, question its protagonist's motivations, and hold its depiction of spiritual mechanics against a framework of true divine sovereignty. The film's value lies not in its conclusion, but in the rigorous intellectual and spiritual self-examination it demands of its audience. It is a dark song, and one must be firmly rooted in the light to appreciate its composition without being drawn into its dissonant melody. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 08/26/25 Full Review Claudio C A Dark Song (2016) Overrated and Boring Horror Film with Messy Conclusion (11,847 – 28 Apr 2017 / 22 Jul 2025 – by Claudio Carvalho) Sophia Howard (Catherine Walker) rents a house in the countryside of Wales and hires the occultist Joseph Solomon (Steve Oram) to contact his son that was kidnapped and murdered by teenagers practicing black magic. During the days, Sophia follows the guidance of Solomon in rituals to purify her soul. However, Sophia has a hidden agenda that jeopardizes their lives. "A Dark Song" is an independent low-budget horror movie by the unknown Liam Gavin. The boring and theatrical screenplay is promising until the awful and messy conclusion that goes nowhere. The only good point are the performances of Catherine Walker and Steve Oram, but it is not worthwhile watching this film. My vote is three. Title (Brazil): Not Available My Blog: https://maniacosporfilme.wordpress.com/ Rated 1.5/5 Stars •  Rated 1.5 out of 5 stars 07/23/25 Full Review Dan S This isn’t just a horror film—it’s a spiritual ordeal. Liam Gavin’s debut feature is a stripped-down, emotionally intense chamber piece that explores grief, guilt, and transcendence through the lens of ceremonial magic. What begins as a story of obsession slowly reveals itself as something far more tender and profound. Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 06/25/25 Full Review Scott P Good movie. Only the very ending is a little Mehhh. But really excellent exploration in the invocation ritual via the grimoire. 👍👍👍 Rated 4/5 Stars •  Rated 4 out of 5 stars 06/15/25 Full Review Music Videos I There’s so much about this film I like, this is the type of movie I generally enjoy. It comes close to being great, but it just falls short in a couple of areas. Firstly, it’s too long, and that’s not something I would usually say, but it becomes a little stodgy in the middle and you could pretty easily cut fifteen minutes to sharpen it up. Secondly, it built well and I was prepared for an ending which was really going to hit me emotionally. But it didn’t really do that as well as it could. I didn’t hate the ending but it didn’t quite impact as much as I was expecting. It’s a good film, well acted, nice cinematography, interesting and intelligent plot, no massive issues with it, but for me it misses out on being top tier. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 05/31/25 Full Review Read all reviews

A Dark Song

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now