Darkness Falls

Audience Reviews

View More (1000+)

Justin B. This was absolute torture. The storyline is all over the place, the rules the movie makes don't make sense, and we abandon ideas that could be interesting, early on. Rated 1/5 Stars •  Rated 1 out of 5 stars 10/29/25 Full Review TheMovieSearch R Darkness Falls is one of those early 2000s horror films that slipped through the cracks but deserves far more recognition than it ever received. Often dismissed as just another supernatural thriller of its era, the movie actually holds up surprisingly well thanks to its eerie atmosphere, tight pacing, and, most importantly, Emma Caulfield’s phenomenal performance. She carries the film with such conviction and emotional depth that it’s impossible not to root for her from start to finish. Caulfield, known for her versatility and natural screen presence, gives Darkness Falls a heart that most horror films of its kind lack. Her portrayal radiates both vulnerability and strength, creating a believable protagonist who isn’t just running from a monster, but fighting against her own fear. She makes you feel the terror of the darkness, the suffocating tension of knowing that one wrong move could end it all. There’s an authenticity in her work that elevates the movie beyond the usual genre clichés. The film’s concept — an avenging spirit who kills anyone who glimpses her in the dark — is simple yet effective. It taps into that primal fear of the dark that lingers in all of us. The director does an impressive job of maintaining suspense throughout, rarely letting the audience relax. From the opening sequence to the final showdown, there’s an undercurrent of dread that never really lets go. Even when the screenplay falters, the atmosphere pulls you right back in. Yes, there are moments where the writing could have been stronger. Certain scenes feel rushed or underdeveloped, and some of the supporting characters don’t have much dimension beyond their purpose in the plot. But despite these flaws, the movie’s pacing and sense of danger keep it engaging. It’s the kind of film that doesn’t rely on jump scares alone — instead, it uses shadow, sound, and tension to do the heavy lifting. What’s most frustrating is how forgotten Darkness Falls has become. It had all the makings of a cult classic, but it never got the proper recognition or marketing push it deserved. The studio seemed to wash its hands of it after release, allowing it to fade into obscurity. Yet, if reintroduced to modern audiences — especially through streaming platforms like Netflix or Hulu — it could easily find a second life and a whole new fanbase. Ultimately, Darkness Falls is an underrated gem that deserves to be rediscovered. It’s not perfect, but it succeeds in the most important way a horror film should: it makes you feel something. Whether it’s fear, tension, or empathy for its heroine, it leaves an impression that lingers after the credits roll. Emma Caulfield’s performance alone makes it worth the watch — and her work here should be remembered as one of the standout portrayals in early 2000s horror. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 10/22/25 Full Review Gabriel S Darkness Falls is one of those movies that had potential to be much more, but falls flat within its own simplicity. With only 86 minutes of runtime, the storyline could not develop itself into a much interesting story than what it is, in the end leaving us with something shallow and uneffective. The story starts with a tone-setting scene showing how Kyle fended off the horror of Darkness Falls: a jumpscary b**** of a Tooth Fairy. Lot of years later, and Kyle gets a call from his long lost childhood love asking for help because her little brother is sort of behaving the same way Kyle did back then before his encounter with Miss Tooth. The whole storyline takes place in this one fatidic day. Kyle is reluctant because he himself hasn’t overcome his fears, but he also is empathetic towards Caitlin's little brother Michael for obvious reasons — he still loves Caitlin. Plot-wise, the story unfolds alright, but there are a lot of holes in it. For starters, the title of the film suggests screenwriters and director had something bigger in mind but had to cut shorter significantly. Dialogues hint at the backstory, how the town of Darkness Falls suffers years and years with the terror of the Tooth Fairy, the disappearances of kids, people being sort of bound to the place one way or another. Yet, we get none of that in the story. (And, well, Darkness Falls is such a cliché name for a tormented town, but, then again, we have our Sleepy Hollow and Silent Hill…) Now, Kyle (Chaney Kley — Andrew Garfield lookalike) is OK as the main character, but he, and pretty much everyone else, is a plank. This is probably due to misdirection or a lack of caring for the shallow script. And the character design for the Tooth Fairy is hilarious. Some of the kills are so funny that I could not help but laugh. That and the fact that this b---- is always jumpscarying us on every scene she is in — not for the faint of heart. Overall, Darkness Falls is a lackluster, trying hard to be solid without success. It lacks density and depth, it lacks character development and better acting, it lacks a good conclusion and closure. Can't recommend. Rated 1/5 Stars •  Rated 1 out of 5 stars 07/23/25 Full Review Dahiana M Por momentos me resulto entretenida, aún así no fue una película fascinante. Rated 2/5 Stars •  Rated 2 out of 5 stars 07/20/25 Full Review Tonya K Love this movie. I thought a movie about an evil tooth fairy was an interesting and creative thing to do for a horror film Rated 5/5 Stars •  Rated 5 out of 5 stars 07/14/25 Full Review Justin T It is a really cool concept for the story. Shame that the cast are so forgettable. It’s beautifully shot, especially for a film of this time. Really beautifully made film. And it sounds good too. There’s a really cool stunt where they crash a car into a tree, in fact there are lots of great sequences. This is one of the best Hollywood horrors from this time. It does lose its energy and interest in the middle, it could have done with more layers, but then it really picks up in the final act. Some of the extras don’t react to extreme situations like when the guy is violently arrested and the doctor just stands there. Overall I really enjoyed it, shame the casting wasn’t better. Rated 3.5/5 Stars •  Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 05/07/25 Full Review Read all reviews

Darkness Falls

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now