Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows FanStore News Showtimes

The Silence

Play trailer Poster for The Silence Released Nov 10, 1999 1h 16m Drama Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
83% Tomatometer 6 Reviews 77% Popcornmeter 100+ Ratings
A blind 10-year-old (Tahmineh Normatova) tunes musical instruments to earn money for his mother, abandoned by his father years earlier.

Where to Watch

The Silence

Critics Reviews

View All (6) Critics Reviews
Robert Davis Paste Magazine The boy's blindness often seems like either a novelty or a symbol; in either case, its falseness weakens the overall effect, even though the film easily has a dozen charming, memorable scenes. Rated: 3/5 Jun 5, 2008 Full Review Emanuel Levy EmanuelLevy.Com Rated: 3/5 Jul 7, 2005 Full Review Jake Euker F5 (Wichita, KS) Rated: 4/5 Jun 12, 2005 Full Review Christopher Null Filmcritic.com a puzzle about what the entire experience was supposed to be all about. Rated: 3/5 Aug 19, 2003 Full Review John A. Nesbit Old School Reviews turn off the cell phone, shut out the outside distractions, and follow Makhmalbaf's sumptuous visuals and sounds to get inside Khorshid's world. Rated: B Oct 29, 2002 Full Review Dennis Schwartz Dennis Schwartz Movie Reviews Makhmalbaf shows that there must be a marriage between the East and West, if his country is to become more enlightened. Rated: B Mar 11, 2002 Full Review Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View All (11) audience reviews
isla s This is an insightful film about a blind boy in Tajikistan who works for a local instrument maker and what happens when he travels in to work each day. It's interesting to hear the traditional music and see the surroundings of such a foreign place. It's also surprising how well the boy (Khorsid) gets on given his blindness. This is a relatively short but interesting and enjoyable watch which I'd recommend for fans of world cinema, yes. Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 03/31/23 Full Review Audience Member This film features fabulous cinematography but not much else. I watched the entire thing because I was mesmerised by the colorful scenes, apparently taken somewhere in Tajikistan. It was fun also to listen to the Tajik language, which is really just a dialect of the Persian spoken in Iran. The problem was that the plot moved so slowly that it was hard to keep track of what was going on. I kept getting distracted by the market scenes and the lake scenes and all those beautiful colors. If you really appreciate good photography, though, it's probably worth watching the movie for that alone. Rated 2.5 out of 5 stars 02/14/23 Full Review Audience Member Mohsen Makhmalbaf shot his 1998 film SOKOUT (The Silence) in Tajikistan, a setting as exotic for his native Iran as for an international audience. As the film opens, we meet the blind boy Khurshid (Tahmineh Normatova) and his mother living on the outskirts of the capital Dushanbe, now recovering from several years of civil war. Each morning their landlord knocks on their door to remind them that the rent is due soon, threatening them with eviction if they don't pay up. Khurshid is employed in a workshop, tuning musical instruments before they are sold. However, his master is increasingly fed up by his tardiness, for on the way to work Khurshid tends to follow any pretty sound he hears. It falls to the master's adopted daughter Nadareh to ensure that Khurshid makes it to work, but she is fascinated by his different perspective on the world around him. This is a film of rich visuals. While Makhmalbaf does portray the poverty and failing infrastructure of Tajikistan, he powerfully draws out the varied colours of the country, as well as the immense ethnic and racial diversity of Transoxiana. One curious focus of SOKOUT is the ambiguous period between girlhood and young womanhood, as Nadareh and another female character of the same age are first introduced with extreme closeups of their lower faces, which make their exact age uncertain. Although still very much a child, Nadareh is shown aspiring to adulthood, drooping cherries over her ears like earrings and placing flower petals over her fingernails as makeshift nail polish. Although memorable and often entertaining, SOKOUT falls short of greatness, for what its plot all means is not clear. There's no closure or resolution, and indeed by the end of the film, things are looking worse for Khorshid and his mother than ever. Perhaps I'm simply missing an allegorical meaning that Makhmalbaf's Iranian audience will pick up on immediately. A couple of interpretations seem likely, and there's a clear attack on religious fundamentalists when Nadareh runs away from a soldier scolding girls without head scarves. But the film remains a great enigma for me. Another flaw is that the use of amateur actors, while it generally makes for authenticity, seems a limitation whenever trained actors come on screen, such as Araz M. Shirmohamadi playing a Turkmen nomad. Still, I do recommend this film very much. Many scenes will stay with you, and this is a glimpse into a part of the world little-known in the West. I've watched SOKOUT several times now, and even if I never succeed in getting it, making another attempt is always an enjoyable 70 minutes. Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 02/08/23 Full Review Audience Member Mohsen Makhmalbaf shot his 1998 film SOKOUT (The Silence) in Tajikistan, a setting as exotic for his native Iran as for an international audience. As the film opens, we meet the blind boy Khurshid (Tahmineh Normatova) and his mother living on the outskirts of the capital Dushanbe, now recovering from several years of civil war. Each morning their landlord knocks on their door to remind them that the rent is due soon, threatening them with eviction if they don't pay up. Khurshid is employed in a workshop, tuning musical instruments before they are sold. However, his master is increasingly fed up by his tardiness, for on the way to work Khurshid tends to follow any pretty sound he hears. It falls to the master's adopted daughter Nadareh to ensure that Khurshid makes it to work, but she is fascinated by his different perspective on the world around him. This is a film of rich visuals. While Makhmalbaf does portray the poverty and failing infrastructure of Tajikistan, he powerfully draws out the varied colours of the country, as well as the immense ethnic and racial diversity of Transoxiana. One curious focus of SOKOUT is the ambiguous period between girlhood and young womanhood, as Nadareh and another female character of the same age are first introduced with extreme closeups of their lower faces, which make their exact age uncertain. Although still very much a child, Nadareh is shown aspiring to adulthood, drooping cherries over her ears like earrings and placing flower petals over her fingernails as makeshift nail polish. Although memorable and often entertaining, SOKOUT falls short of greatness, for what its plot all means is not clear. There's no closure or resolution, and indeed by the end of the film, things are looking worse for Khorshid and his mother than ever. Perhaps I'm simply missing an allegorical meaning that Makhmalbaf's Iranian audience will pick up on immediately. A couple of interpretations seem likely, and there's a clear attack on religious fundamentalists when Nadareh runs away from a soldier scolding girls without head scarves. But the film remains a great enigma for me. Another flaw is that the use of amateur actors, while it generally makes for authenticity, seems a limitation whenever trained actors come on screen, such as Araz M. Shirmohamadi playing a Turkmen nomad. Still, I do recommend this film very much. Many scenes will stay with you, and this is a glimpse into a part of the world little-known in the West. I've watched SOKOUT several times now, and even if I never succeed in getting it, making another attempt is always an enjoyable 70 minutes. Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars 02/08/23 Full Review Audience Member A Fantastic movie.. featuring the story of a blind boy with his poor lonely mother in Tjakistan .. the boy earns his own life by helping tuning musical instruments in traditional workshop.. his passion to music costs him losing his work.. the cinematography is just wonderful.. the music is wonderful and the art of direction in this movie is really a perfect work.. from Mohsen Makhmalbaf.. Rated 4 out of 5 stars 02/13/23 Full Review Audience Member didn't like, nice cinematography but no pace in the movie! Rated 2 out of 5 stars 01/29/23 Full Review Read all reviews
The Silence

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Cast & Crew

The Wind Will Carry Us 97% 84% The Wind Will Carry Us Watchlist Pola X 76% 54% Pola X Watchlist 10 85% 80% 10 Watchlist Not One Less 96% 90% Not One Less Watchlist The Apple 85% 83% The Apple Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Movie Info

Synopsis A blind 10-year-old (Tahmineh Normatova) tunes musical instruments to earn money for his mother, abandoned by his father years earlier.
Director
Mohsen Makhmalbaf
Producer
Marin Karmitz
Screenwriter
Mohsen Makhmalbaf
Genre
Drama
Original Language
Russian
Release Date (Theaters)
Nov 10, 1999, Wide
Release Date (Streaming)
Dec 13, 2018
Box Office (Gross USA)
$32.9K
Runtime
1h 16m
Most Popular at Home Now