TheMovieSearch R
Billy Club is one of those films that makes you wonder how it ever made it past the script stage. From start to finish, it’s a complete disaster of tone, structure, and storytelling—a horror-slasher concept that tries to blend baseball nostalgia with revenge-driven terror, but instead becomes an incoherent mess. The film wants to be gritty and shocking, yet it never finds its footing. Every scene feels like it’s working against itself, with no sense of pacing, rhythm, or logic to hold it together.
The screenplay is where most of the blame lands. It’s muddled, inconsistent, and painfully predictable while somehow also being confusing. The dialogue doesn’t sound natural, the motivations make little sense, and the so-called mystery behind the killings is telegraphed long before it should be. Instead of suspense or tension, the story delivers long stretches of meaningless chatter followed by bursts of awkward, poorly staged violence. There’s no real emotional connection to anyone involved, which makes the horror completely ineffective.
Visually, the film looks cheap and uninspired. It leans into dim lighting and forced atmosphere, but the cinematography and editing only highlight how little craft was put into the final product. There’s no cohesion between scenes, and the tone jumps from campy to deadly serious without any smooth transition. Even the killer’s baseball-themed gimmick, which could have been darkly fun in the right hands, comes off as silly and poorly executed.
The direction is aimless, as if the filmmakers had no clear idea of what kind of movie they wanted to make. It’s part revenge thriller, part slasher, part nostalgic coming-of-age story—but none of those elements work together. The performances don’t help either; the cast delivers their lines with the energy of a bad table read, making even the most intense moments feel flat. There’s no chemistry, no urgency, and no authenticity in any of their interactions.
What’s most frustrating is that there was, in theory, a kernel of potential in the premise—a baseball team haunted by the sins of its past could have been an interesting setup. But Billy Club never builds on that idea. It simply fumbles its way through a series of clichés and uninspired kills, leaving audiences more irritated than entertained.
In the end, Billy Club isn’t just a bad horror movie—it’s a cautionary tale about what happens when a film has no clear vision or competent execution. It’s amateurish on every level, from script to direction to performance. This is the kind of movie that should have been stopped during pre-production and completely reworked from the ground up. As it stands, it’s a strikeout in every sense of the word.
Rated 0.5/5 Stars •
Rated 0.5 out of 5 stars
11/02/25
Full Review
Audience Member
..... well, the plot was pretty much the movie Prom
night with the twist of... the movie not making any sense...
Rated 1/5 Stars •
Rated 1 out of 5 stars
02/03/23
Full Review
Audience Member
Some good moments, but the movie just rambles on. Essentially it is prom night with baseball.
Rated 1/5 Stars •
Rated 1 out of 5 stars
02/27/23
Full Review
Audience Member
This is a fun and exciting indy horror comedy that was funded through Kickstarter. Very indy, very raw, but it was obviously made by horror movie fanatics for horror movie fanatics. I say this is a seven innings out of ten.
Rated 3.5/5 Stars •
Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars
02/08/23
Full Review
Audience Member
"Billy Club" is a modern slasher flick that utilizes classic horror elements in order to create a contemporary nightmare. One that takes America's pastime and twists it into a dark pool of grue that is satirical and disturbing. The film follows four friends reuniting to commemorate the brutal murder of their little league baseball coach and teammates. The event turns deadly as a vengeful, brutal killer forces them to face their past.
The story is a pretty clever, dark piece of horror that draws on tradition slasher elements like the surrealist atmosphere, horrific backstory, and plenty of blood and gore. "Billy Club" starts with a terrible tragedy that comes back to haunt all those involved. Totally typical and completely perfect for any slasher. It is a set-up that I personally feel never becomes tired. Rosas and Sommers manage to bring out a nostalgia and adoration for classic 80's horror while creating a truly individual horror story and truly inventive masked slasher. One that is sure to be a modern day slasher icon worthy of franchising.
The acting and direction of the film is pretty standard with a cast that is rough in spots hitting the dialog and timing, but honestly no more than so many films that have come before it. Films that I find myself watching over and over. There are a few too many flashback moments in the film that can seem confusing but really fit when you get to the ending. The ending is one that is clever, well hidden until the very end and really solidifies "Billy Club" as worthy of the awards it has won. The humor is not the comedy "spoof" stuff but a blend of characters that fit into the "loveable losers" category and drug induced humor. It does seem to confuse the overall dark nature of the material but only in the way that several of the characters in the "Friday The 13th" franchise do for those films.
The special effects are all practical, organic, and traditional-no CGI here, at least none that I could tell. The directors never shy away from the kill scenes and showing the gruesomeness of it all, the effects artist has is consistency and quality at a level that the directors don't have to "insinuate" the brutality so deaths are pretty cool and graphic. The sound effects are a bit garden variety creepiness but work well to create a chilling environment for this nightmare to unfold. The effects in one final scene aren't quite as stellar as the rest of the film's gory effects but whatever, 95% of the slaugherfest in "Billy Club" is pretty tight.
Overall "Billy Club" is a worthy slasher film that is an instant cult classic. I enjoyed this film immensely, I connected with the vibe of little league having played up until JV, the nods and homage to classic 80's slashers are tasteful and not rip-offs, and the killer is just a nightmare. Truly creative and menacing. The cinematography is done nicely, enough of the film happens in darkness (which is how a horror film should be), the scenery and sets are odd, eerie elements that just amp up the chilling subject matter. But mostly the guts and gore are the big draw for horror fans to the film. Definitely check this one out! - See more at: http://asouthernlifeinscandaloustimes.blogspot.com/2014/10/my-review-of-billy-club.html#sthash.2Bdem3XJ.dpuf
Rated 4/5 Stars •
Rated 4 out of 5 stars
01/12/23
Full Review
Audience Member
If Ryan Plato weren't in it, it would have been better than "Blood Junkie". Instead, Plato makes an appearance, and therefore makes the movie just as good as "Blood Junkie". Thankfully, "Blood Junkie" is a solid flick. "Billy Club" is too, but in different ways. Its antagonist is far more interesting, as is the film's conclusion. "Billy Club" also trades itself up in the seriousness department, and it makes for a film that feels odd at first but keeps legs going into the final act.
"Billy Club" is Arpke Approved at 4 out of 5 stars
Rated 4/5 Stars •
Rated 4 out of 5 stars
02/22/23
Full Review
Read all reviews
Continue with Google
>
